Combining the Creative Arts and the House Call to Teach Medical Students About Chronic Illness Care

Abstract

As the number of people living with chronic illness in the United States rises, it is imperative that medical school prepare physicians who are capable of caring for these patients. This article outlines a creative educational intervention to teach third-and fourth-year medical students about caring for chronically ill people. All students at Weill Medical College, Cornell University, make home visits to homebound older adults with an interdisciplinary team as part of a mandatory Primary Care Clerkship. Under their guidance, students observe the myriad challenges facing homebound older adults. Afterward, students create a project, using original or found art, to express their reactions and thoughts. Students present projects to peers in a small group, with multidisciplinary faculty mentors framing the discussion. To evaluate the intervention, students responded to a nine-item questionnaire and a series of openended questions. Quantitative and qualitative analyses show consistently strong positive responses to the experience. Most students (95.0%) felt that they learned about the complexities of chronic illness care from their home visits. The opportunity to express reactions through a creative project received positive responses with 97.0% of students responding favorably. Ninety-seven percent felt that the discussions with colleagues and faculty increased knowledge of chronic illness care. Nearly all (97.0%) felt they had a better understanding of team and that attitudes toward the chronically ill were positively affected. The coupling of the creative arts with home visits is an effective tool for teaching about chronic illness and may be a useful model for medical schools interested in expanding their chronic illness curriculum. J Am Geriatr Soc 58: 346-351, 2010.

Rethinking research in the medical humanities: a scoping review and narrative synthesis of quantitative outcome studies

“…Art was assumed to provide experiences that stimulate emotional learning and to be beneficial in teaching students self‐awareness, self‐discovery and personal growth on their way to becoming professionals. In addition to the intrinsic value of personal growth and insight, the use of art in this group of studies is also described as creating space in which to discuss and process difficult and often suppressed aspects of being a physician, such as dealing with death and dying, suffering, one's mistakes and own vulnerabilities, and medicine's limitations . Thus, many papers in this grouping describe art as having emancipatory goals and as providing a means of equipping students with the emotional resilience they require to better face systematic problems, including physician burnout, stress and decreasing empathy.…”

A review of creative and expressive writing as a pedagogical tool in medical education

“…These were evaluated by two authors. Ninety‐one articles were selected that met the inclusion criteria for the review: 28 position paper overviews, six reviews, one meta‐analysis, two surveys, 19 quasi‐experimental studies, 10 mixed‐methods studies and 25 qualitative studies …”

“…Among the 54 outcome studies (19 quasi‐experimental studies, 10 mixed‐methods studies and 25 qualitative studies …”

“…Navigating these challenging situations is known to be a difficult rite of passage for students. The opportunity for reflection through writing was seen as useful for medical students in emotionally challenging situations …”

Training Health Care Professionals for 21st-Century Practice

“…Health System Organization of Health Care 57 Desguin 45 Lausen et al 63 LoFaso et al 46 Mullen et al 47 Nieman & Cheng 60 O'Connell et al 52 Schreier et al 48 Shapiro et al 49 Waddell & Davidson 44 (N = 10) Dent et al 53 Diederiks et al 54 Janson et al 64 Jerant et at 55 Lennon-Dearing et al 58 LoFaso et al 46 Nuovo et al 51 Plake 50 Stevens et al 65 Shapiro et al 49 (N = 10)…”