In this paper we briefly discuss the necessity of using quantum mechanics as a fundamental theory applicable to some key functional aspects of biological systems. This is especially relevant to three important parts of a neuron in the human brain, namely the cell membrane, microtubules (MT) and ion channels. We argue that the recently published papers criticizing the use of quantum theory in these systems are not convincing.
1) Quantum theory and biological systemsBiological systems operate within the framework of irreversible thermodynamics and nonlinear kinetic theory of open systems, both of which are based on the principles of nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. The search for physically-based fundamental models in biology that can provide a conceptual bridge between the chemical organization of living organisms and the phenomenal states of life and experience has generated a vigorous and so far inconclusive debate [1,2]. Recently published experimental evidence has provided support for the hypothesis that biological systems use some type of quantum coherence in their functions. The nearly 100% efficient excitation energy transfer in photosynthesis is an excellent example [3]. Living systems are composed of molecules and atoms, and the most advanced physical theory describing interactions between atoms and molecules is quantum mechanics. For example, making and breaking of chemical bonds, absorbance of frequency specific radiation (e.g. in photosynthesis and vision), conversion of chemical energy into mechanical motion (e.g. ATP cleavage) and single electron transfer through biological polymers (e.g. in DNA or proteins) are all quantum effects. Regarding the efficient functioning of biological systems, the relevant question to ask is how can a biological system with billions of semi-autonomous components function effectively and coherently? Why providing a complete explanation remains a major challenge, quantum coherence is a plausible mechanism responsible for the efficiency and co-ordination exhibited by biological systems [4].