Abstract. It is known that five points in 3 generically determine a finite number of cylinders containing those points. We discuss ways in which it can be shown that the generic (complex) number of solutions, with multiplicity, is six, of which an even number will be real valued and hence correspond to actual cylinders in 3 . We partially classify the case of no real solutions in terms of the geometry of the five given points. We also investigate the special case where the five given points are coplanar, as it differs from the generic case for both complex and real valued solution cardinalities.