Communication skills assessment in the final postgraduate years to established practice: a systematic review

Abstract

Introduction Communication breakdown is a factor in the majority of all instances of medical error. Despite the importance, a relative paucity of time is invested in communication skills in postgraduate curricula. Our objective is to systematically review the literature to identify the current tools used to assess communication skills in postgraduate trainees in the latter 2 years of training and in established practice. Methods Two reviewers independently reviewed the literature identifying communication skill assessment tools, for postgraduate trainees in the latter 2 years of training and in established practice following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses framework, and inclusion/exclusion criteria from January 1990 to 15 August 2014. Databases: PubMed/CINAHL/ERIC/EMBASE/PsycInfo/Psyc Articles/Cochrane. Results 222 articles were identified; after review, 34 articles fulfilled criteria for complete evaluation; the majority (26) had a high level of evidence scoring 3 or greater on the Best Evidence Medical Education guide. 22 articles used objective structured clinical examination/standardised patient (SP)-based formats in an assessment or training capacity. Evaluation tools included author-developed questionnaires and validated tools. Nineteen articles demonstrated an educational initiative. Conclusions The reviewed literature is heterogeneous for objectives and measurement techniques for communication. Observed interactions, with patients or SPs, is the current favoured method of evaluation using author-developed questionnaires. The role of self-evaluation of skill level is questioned. The need for a validated assessment tool for communication skills is highlighted.

Improving the Informed Consent Conversation: A Standardized Checklist that Is Patient Centered, Quality Driven, and Legally Sound

“…Despite the national call to improve the informed consent conversation, the persistent deficiencies may result in part from the lack of a validated tool to teach or evaluate communication skills at the postgraduate level (64). It may also result from a lack of full awareness regarding the extent and impact of limited health literacy (33).…”

Associations between social skills and burnout dimensions in medical residents

“…The recognition that effective communication contributes to successful medical practice has been widely reported in the literature (Beckman & Frankel, 2003;Fournier et al, 2014;Gillis, Morris, & Ridgway, 2015). Although the present study did not specifically address the doctorpatient relationship, some skills assessed by the factors self-assertion in the expression of positive affection and conversation and social confidence include various communication skills -such as giving thanks and praise; asking questions; and participating in a conversation, keeping it flowing and ending it -, which can be useful when interacting with patients, colleagues, and supervisors.…”

Avaliação de Habilidades de Comunicação em Ambiente Simulado na Formação Médica: Conceitos, Desafios e Possibilidades

“…Apesar da crescente valorização, ainda não há consenso sobre o que seria uma comunicação médico-paciente adequada 24,25 . O Consenso de Kalamazoo 22 , baseando-se em cinco modelos teóricos de comunicação médico-paciente, determinou sete componentes-chave que caracterizam a comunicação adequada no contexto clínico:…”

“…O OSCE é considerado um exame de elevada aceitabilidade tanto entre educadores quanto estudantes 32 . Seu im-pacto educacional positivo e as evidências de validade de seus resultados levaram à incorporação do método ao processo de avaliação de estudantes de Medicina em todo o mundo, tanto em avaliações que fundamentam decisões de alto impacto (aprovação/reprovação, seleção, certificação profissional) quanto formativas 20,21,24,25,43,47,55,57 . A cultura institucional, os altos custos e o elevado consumo de tempo em sua elaboração e execução são desafios a serem vencidos 20 .…”