Communication Structures and Decision Making Cues and Criteria to Support Effective Drought Warning in Central Malawi

Abstract

Early warning systems trigger early action and enable better disaster preparedness. People-centered dissemination and communication are pivotal for the effective uptake of early warnings. Current research predominantly focuses on sudden-onset hazards, such as floods, ignoring considerable differences with slow-onset hazards, such as droughts. We identify the essential factors contributing to effective drought dissemination and communication using the people-centered approach advocated in the WMOs Multi-Hazard Early Warning System Framework (MHEWS). We use semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders and focus group discussions with small-scale farmers in the Mangochi and Salima Districts of Malawi. We show that the timely release of seasonal forecast, the tailoring of the drought warning content (and its timing) to agricultural decision making, and the provision of several dissemination channels enhance trust and improve uptake of drought warning information by farmers. Our analysis demonstrates that farmers seek, prepare, and respond to drought warning information when it is provided as advice on agricultural practices, rather than as weather-related information. The information was found to be useful where it offers advice on the criteria and environmental cues that farmers can use to inform their decisions in a timely manner. Based on our findings, we propose that by focusing on enhancing trust, improving information uptake and financial sustainability as key metrics, the MHEWS can be adapted for use in monitoring the effectiveness of early warning systems.

Exploring the integration of local and scientific knowledge in early warning systems for disaster risk reduction: a review

“…To prevent or mitigate these increasing impacts of disasters due to climate-related hazards, anticipatory action for local contexts is essential (IFRC 2021). In 2008, the Red Cross Red Crescent movement introduced Forecast-based Financing (FbF) as one of the first forms of anticipatory action (van den Homberg et al 2020). FbF enables access to the so-called Disaster Response Emergency Fund, a funding source habitually only available for humanitarian response, before a disaster has happened.…”

Connecting hydrological modelling and forecasting from global to local scales: Perspectives from an international joint virtual workshop

“…A relevant example is the use of seasonal forecasts and drought warnings by farmers in Malawi ([MW-K]; Calvel et al, 2020;Mittal et al, 2020;Streefkerk et al, 2022). Through focus group discussions, researchers developed an understanding of the seasonal calendar of local farmers' activities.…”

Editorial: Climate Science Advances to Address 21st Century Weather and Climate Extremes

“…This translation can add great value. For example, a recent study of drought warning activities in Malawi, found that what farmers really wanted and needed was agricultural advice, not weather data (Calvel et al, 2020), i.e., knowledgeable actionable guidance, not just data or information.…”