Community health worker support to improve HIV treatment outcomes for older children and adolescents in Zimbabwe: a process evaluation of the ZENITH trial

Abstract

BackgroundCommunity health worker (CHW)-delivered support visits to children living with HIV and their caregivers significantly reduced odds of virological failure among the children in the ZENITH trial conducted in Zimbabwe. We conducted a process evaluation to assess fidelity, acceptability, and feasibility of this intervention to identify lessons that could inform replication and scale-up of this approach.MethodsField manuals kept by each CHW, records from monthly supervisory meetings, and participant data collected throughout the trial were used to assess the intervention’s implementation. Data extracted from field manuals included visit type, content, and duration. Minutes from monthly supervisory meetings were used to capture CHW attendance.ResultsThe trial enrolled 172 participants in the intervention arm of whom 5 subsequently refused all visits, 1 died before the intervention could be delivered, and 1 could not be located. Manuals for 8 participants were not returned, 3 were incorrectly entered, and 1 manual was lost. We had 154 manuals available for analysis.A total of 1553 visits were successfully conducted (median 11 per participant, range 1–20). Additionally, CHWs made 85 visits where they were unable to make contact with the family. Thirteen (8.4%) participants received 5 or fewer visits, 10 moved out of the study area, and 3 died. CHWs discussed disclosure with the child/family for over 89% of participants and assisted clients with developing and reviewing their personal treatment plan with over 85% of participants. Of the 20 CHWs (3 male, 17 female) selected to implement the intervention, 19 were retained at the end of the trial.ConclusionsThe intervention was acceptable to participants with most receiving and accepting the required number of visits. Key strenghts were high staff retention and fidelity to the intervention. This community-based intervention was an acceptable and feasible approach to reduce virological failure among children living with HIV.Trial registrationThe ZENITH trial was registered on 25 October 2012 in the Pan African Clinical Trials Registry under the trial registration number PACTR201212000442288. It can be found at http://www.pactr.org/ATMWeb/appmanager/atm/atmregistry?dar=true&tNo=PACTR201212000442288.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s13012-018-0762-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The Roles of Social Auxiliary Workers in Drop-in-Centres: Addressing the Biopsychosocial Needs of Children Living With Hiv

“…Participants highlight vital factors such as secrecy and the socio-emotional consequences for all. These responses fit well with the findings of Chikwari, Simms, Busza, Dauya, Bandason, Chonzi, Munyati, Mujuru and Ferrand (2018) from an evaluation of community support programmes to improve HIV treatment outcomes for children and adolescents in Zimbabwe. The study established that refusal of HIV disclosure to children by parents creates multiple barriers, including obstruction of access and adherence to ART, and understanding at an early age of the impact of sexual activity on the spread of HIV.…”

“I have never talked to anyone to free my mind” – challenges surrounding status disclosure to adolescents contribute to their disengagement from HIV care: a qualitative study in western Kenya

“…In Ghana, a randomized trial demonstrated that a therapeutic communication and personalized interaction to promote disclosure integrated in HIV care visits resulted in increased disclosure at each study timepoint [ 34 ]. In Zimbabwe, a community health worker intervention supporting children with HIV and their caregivers with multiple components included assessments of pediatric disclosure and dedicated support for disclosure and discussions, and resulted in improved virologic suppression [ 35 ]. Further insights may be gleaned from the Amagugu intervention, a counselor-led home-based intervention supporting disclosure of maternal HIV status to HIV-uninfected children, given some anticipated common barriers driving caregiver hesitancies to disclose [ 36 , 37 ].…”

Global, regional and country-level 90–90–90 estimates for 2018

“…Although the availability of new medicines such as dolutegravir that offer a faster and sustained pathway to viral suppression (even among those who fail with older integrase inhibitors) will help, communitycentred activities to help support adherence to treatment are paramount [2,41]. Strategies that use peers and trained community health workers have been shown to produce retention rates and treatment outcomes on par with those reported in traditional healthcare delivery settings [42][43][44]. Viral load testing is critical to identify patients who do not have suppressed viral load and initiate adherence support or a switch to second-line or third-line therapy, as appropriate.…”