Comparative copper sensitivity between life stages of common subantarctic marine invertebrates

Abstract

The development of environmental guidelines in the Antarctic and subantarctic is essential, because expansion of research, tourism, and fishing is placing these regions at increasing risk of contamination. Data are currently insufficient to create the region-specific guidelines needed for the unique conditions in these areas. To develop the most appropriate environmental guidelines, data from the most sensitive life stages of a species should be included to ensure effective protection throughout its life cycle. It is generally accepted that early life stages are more sensitive to contaminants. We compared the toxicity of copper between juvenile and adult life stages of 4 subantarctic marine invertebrates using sublethal and lethal endpoints. For 2 of the species tested, juveniles were more sensitive than adults. (The 7-d median effect concentration [EC50] values for the gastropod Laevilittorina caliginosa were 79 μg/L at the juvenile stage and 125 μg/L at the adult; for the flatworm Obrimoposthia ohlini, values were 190 μg/L at the juvenile stage and 300 μg/L at the adult.) For the isopod Limnoria stephenseni, juveniles were either more sensitive or of equal sensitivity to adults (7-d EC50 values: juvenile 278 μg/L and adult 320 μg/L). In contrast, for the bivalve Gaimardia trapesina, adults appeared to be more sensitive than young adults (7-d EC50 values: juvenile 23 μg/L and adult <10-20 μg/L). Although no consistent trend in the sensitivity of life history stages was observed, the present study contributes important information for the development of water quality guidelines in polar regions. Environ Toxicol Chem 2018;37:807-815. © 2017 SETAC.

Sensitivity of a Large and Representative Sample of Antarctic Marine Invertebrates to Metals

“…For many species, 4 d was the minimum duration required to see a substantial effect on mortality, and was reported in the present study, because this is commonly used in tests with temperate species. A test duration of 10 d has previously been used in tests with Antarctic and subantarctic species (e.g., Payne et al ; Marcus Zamora et al ; Holan et al , , ), and provides a good compromise between the shortest duration required to consistently see a response, and the extended duration that is appropriate for cold‐climate species with slow metabolic rates. For some cold‐climate species, even longer test durations (up to 4 wk) have been used (e.g., Sfiligoj et al ; Brown et al ) and may have provided more sensitive results, but, to be in keeping with the premise of the rapid method, these durations were impractical and beyond the scope of our study.…”

Using an expert judgment response matrix to assess the risk of groundwater discharges from remediated fuel spill sites to the marine environment at sub‐Antarctic Macquarie Island, Australia

“…Test methodologies based on previous work were used for 7 species: Zaus sp., T. angulatus , Laevilitorina caliginosa , M. hamiltoni , G. trapesina , and O. ohlini (Holan et al 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019), and E. gigas (Lewis et al 2016). For the remaining 4 species, test methodologies were developed during the present study (full test method details are available in King et al 2020).…”

Neonicotinoid Insecticides from a Marine Perspective: Acute and Chronic Copepod Testing and Derivation of Environmental Quality Standards

“…It is commonly recognized that early-life stages are usually more sensitive than adult organisms of the same species, but exceptions do exist. Holan et al (2018) found adult individuals of the marine bivalve Gaimardia trapesina to be more sensitive than juveniles when exposed to copper (Holan et al 2018). Since one of the overarching goals of the derivation of EQS is to protect species at a population level, there is no clear reason for not including acute EC 10 values in the derivation of the AA-EQS.…”