Comparative Efficiency and Sensitivity Analysis of AC and DC Power Distribution Paradigms for Residential Localities

Abstract

The new millennium has witnessed a pervasive shift of trend from AC to DC in residential sector. The shift of trend is predominantly due to independent residential solar PV systems at rooftops and escalating electronic loads with better energy saving potential integrated with diminishing prices as well as commercial availability of DC based appliances. DC has ousted AC in generation, transmission, and utilization sectors with the advent of DC based generating systems (e-g solar PV), high voltage DC (HVDC) transmission and the utilization of DC based loads respectively. However, the war of currents (AC vs DC) is still ON as regards to distribution sector. Efficiency is the parameter that once wiped DC out of the power systems scenario as compared to AC-at the time of Tesla and Edison. Therefore, the same parameter is utilized to determine which is better for distribution sector under current conditions; AC or DC? A comprehensive sensitivity analysis considering real load profile is missing in the present body of knowledge. In order to fill that gap, this paper is an attempt to include comprehensive sensitivity analysis of DC distribution system and its simulation-based comparison with AC counterpart considering real load profile. The paper uses Monte Carlo technique and probabilistic approach to add diversity in residential loads consumption and in turn to obtain instantaneous load profile. The paper also presents a futuristic perspective of power electronic converter (PEC) efficiency variation on the efficiency comparison of both AC and DC distribution systems. Since the present body of knowledge generally compares AC and DC distribution based upon assumptions and limited scenarios which results in conflicting outcomes; in contrast, the discoveries of the current examination are useful to reduce the confusions and conflictions regarding which is better at distribution scale; AC or DC?