Among the many proteins used to repair DNA double-strand breaks by nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) are two related family X DNA polymerases, Pol λ and Pol μ. Which of these two polymerases is preferentially used for filling DNA gaps during NHEJ partly depends on sequence complementarity at the break, with Pol λ and Pol μ repairing complementary and noncomplementary ends, respectively. To better understand these substrate preferences, we present crystal structures of Pol μ on a 2-nt gapped DNA substrate, representing three steps of the catalytic cycle. In striking contrast to Pol λ, Pol μ "skips" the first available template nucleotide, instead using the template base at the 5′ end of the gap to direct nucleotide binding and incorporation. This remarkable divergence from canonical 3′-end gap filling is consistent with data on end-joining substrate specificity in cells, and provides insights into polymerase substrate choices during NHEJ.DNA polymerase mu | DNA polymerase lambda | DNA repair | nonhomologous end joining D NA double-strand breaks (DSBs) result from exposure to endogenous and exogenous factors including reactive oxygen species, physical or mechanical stress, ionizing radiation, or activities of nuclear enzymes on DNA (1). Another source of DSBs is programmed DNA breakage during meiotic or mitotic recombination, immunoglobin gene rearrangement in V(D)J, and class-switch recombination (1, 2). Because of the largely random nature of accidental double-strand breakage, the broken ends can have widely varying sequences, structures, or modifications. Nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) is the predominant form of DSB repair in higher eukaryotes, and requires a certain degree of flexibility from the many factors involved in this complex repair process.DSB substrates lacking microhomology at the break site are unsuitable for immediate rejoining by ligase IV, and a polymerase is usually required to fill the gaps to generate ends that can be efficiently ligated (3). In higher eukaryotes, this role is performed by family X polymerase λ (Pol λ) and polymerase μ (Pol μ) (4-6). Pol λ has a strong preference for substrates with complementary template-strand pairing opposite the primer terminus. Pol μ can also use such complementary DSB substrates, but is uniquely active in template-dependent synthesis on DSBs entirely lacking complementarity, where the primer terminus is unpaired (7).Given partial overlap in substrate use in vitro by Pol μ and Pol λ, how does the NHEJ machinery select which enzyme to repair specific substrates with the highest fidelity? Recent work by Pryor et al. (8) (companion article in this issue) has demonstrated a strong preference for Pol λ over Pol μ in repairing the majority of complementary DSBs. This is advantageous, because Pol λ displays higher fidelity of synthesis (9, 10). However, Pol λ cannot use noncomplementary DSB substrates with unpaired primer termini. Pol μ is the only known polymerase that can use noncomplementary substrates, such that in Pol μ knockout cells, these ends are larg...