Comparative study of three common bile duct closure techniques after choledocholithotomy: safety and efficacy

Abstract

Purpose T-tube drainage, primary closure, and biliary stenting are the common bile duct closure methods. There is great debate on the optimal duct closure technique after common bile duct exploration. This study aimed to assess the safety and efficacy of the three commonest common bile duct closure methods after common bile duct exploration for common bile duct stone for future generalization. Methods In this analysis, 211 patients with common bile duct stone underwent common bile duct exploration from January 2016 to December 2020. The patients were divided according to common bile duct closure techniques into three groups, including the T-tube drainage group (63 patients), primary duct closure group (61 patients), and antegrade biliary stenting group (87 patients). Results The incidence of overall biliary complications and bile leak were statistically significantly lower in the biliary stenting group than in the other two groups. Also, hospital stays, drain carried time, return to normal activity, re-intervention, and re-admission rates were statistically significantly lower in the biliary stenting group than in the other two groups. There were no statistically significant differences regarding operative and choledochotomy time, retained and recurrent stone, stricture, biliary peritonitis, cholangitis, and the cost among the three groups. Conclusions We state that the biliary stenting procedure should be the preferred first option for common bile duct closure after common bile duct exploration when compared with T-tube drainage and primary duct closure. Trial registration ClinicalTrials.gov PRS (Approval No. NCT04264299).

T‑tube versus internal drainage tube in laparoscopic common bile duct exploration

“…Sediment-like stones, inflammatory flocculants and blood clots may cause blockage of the internal drainage tube. Therefore, T-tubes should be used when there are sediment-like stones and inflammatory flocculants in the common bile duct ( 17 ).…”