Comparing Apples and Pears: Women's Perceptions of Their Body Size and Shape

Abstract

Background: Obesity is a growing public health problem among reproductive-aged women, with consequences for chronic disease risk and reproductive and obstetric morbidities. Evidence also suggests that body shape (i.e., regional fat distribution) may be independently associated with risk, yet it is not known if women adequately perceive their shape. This study aimed to assess the validity of self-reported body size and shape figure drawings when compared to anthropometric measures among reproductive-aged women. Methods: Self-reported body size was ascertained using the Stunkard nine-level figures and self-reported body shape using stylized pear, hourglass, rectangle, and apple figures. Anthropometry was performed by trained researchers. Body size and body mass index (BMI) were compared using Spearman's correlation coefficient. Fat distribution indicators were compared across body shapes for nonobese and obese women using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Fisher's exact test. Percent agreement and kappa statistics were computed for apple and pear body shapes. Results: The 131 women studied were primarily Caucasian (81%), aged 32 years, with a mean BMI of 27.1 kg/m

Body Size and Risk of Spontaneous Abortion among Danish Pregnancy Planners

“…Validation studies of similar populations have found that women tend to underestimate these measurements, though secondary analyses among women who used a tape measure in our cohort produced similar results. Tendency to gain weight was also not verified, but one study found that self‐reported female body shape was consistent with anthropometric measures used to assess fat distribution. Exposure misclassification in this study is expected to be nondifferential and bias associations for the extreme categories toward the null.…”

World Endometriosis Research Foundation Endometriosis Phenome and biobanking harmonization project: II. Clinical and covariate phenotype data collection in endometriosis research

“…The anthropometric exposures captured are body mass index (BMI; current height and weight), most and least weighed since age 18, somatotype by age range ( 64 ), and body shape by age range ( 65 ). Current BMI has been shown to be inversely associated with endometriosis ( 66 ) and validly measured by self-reported questionnaire ( 67 – 69 ).…”

Balancing body perception during growth and development

“…This finding suggests that girls rely more on WC than BMI when forming their body perception, possibly because WC is more clearly related to abdominal fat and changes in body shape at different ages. The focus on body parts other than the parameters of weight and height and body shape may reflect current physical ideals, as suggested by other studies (96,97). Bergström et al found that adolescents (without anorexia nervosa) overestimated their body size, particularly at the waist, buttocks and thighs (96).…”