Comparing Serious Violent Crime in the United States and England and Wales

Abstract

This chapter shows how reasonably valid comparative data for violent crime in the United States and England and Wales can be derived. Comparative analysis of violent crime is hampered by a lack of reliable statistics, even between relatively similar countries, with doubts about existing studies suggesting that further comparative data are needed. Violent crime presents particular problems of variation in offense definition and recording practices. However, the data for the United States and England and Wales can be derived for the narrower category of serious violent crime. The chapter shows broadly that the incidence of serious violent crime per capita is between three and seven times as high in the United States as in England and Wales. This parallels the comparative data on homicide; existing comparisons with Canada and New Zealand lend further weight to the claim that levels of serious violence in the United States are distinctively high.

Penal controls and social controls: Toward a theory of American penal exceptionalism

“…The widespread availability of guns undoubtedly escalates American lethal violence, but non-firearm homicides are also higher in the US than in other western nations (Grinshteyn and Hemenway 2016). Despite the downward trend of the last two decades, America's homicide rate remains four times as high as comparable nations, while its rates of armed robbery (Currie 2013;Gallo et al 2018;Sharkey 2018) and police-civilian killings (Karabel 2017) are also markedly higher.…”

Penal power in America: Forms, functions and foundations

“…But it does not follow that penal policy is never driven by crime rates and by different from those typically experienced by the nations of Western Europe. As Zimring and Hawkins (1997) pointed out years ago, and as Miller (2015) Roth (2017 and Gallo et al (2017) have recently reminded us, America has extraordinarily high rates of homicide and these comparatively high rates increased dramatically between the 1960s and the early 1990s. High levels of life-threatening violence change how people react to crime.…”