Comparison of Discrete-Fracture and Dual-Permeability Models for Multiphase Flow in Naturally Fractured Reservoirs

Abstract

Two discrete-fracture models (DFMs) based on different, independent numerical techniques have been developed for studying the behavior of naturally fractured reservoirs. One model is based on unstructured gridding with local refinement near fractures, while in the second model fractures are embedded in a structured matrix grid. Both models capture the complexity of a typical fractured reservoir better than conventional dual-permeability models, leading to a more accurate representation of fractured reservoirs. The accuracy of the DFM approaches is confirmed by their match with a structured, grid-aligned, explicit-fracture model in tests involving capillary imbibition during water flooding and gravity drainage in oil-gas systems. The DFMs are insensitive to grid orientation. Simulations also show consistency and agreement of results of the DFM methods in synthetic models with complex fracture patterns. Our simulations indicate that conventional dual-permeability approaches are appropriate when the fracture system is very sparse relative to the grid spacing. In these situations a DFM can be used as the basis for defining dual-permeability model parameters. However, conventional dual-permeability approaches are inadequate in the presence of high localized anisotropy and preferential channeling. When used with general purpose reservoir simulators, both DFMs show computational performance that is comparable to that of dual-permeability models.

A multi-continuum multiple flow mechanism simulator for unconventional oil and gas recovery

“…EDFM (Lee et al, 2001;Li and Lee, 2008;Moinfar et al, 2011Moinfar et al, , 2014, in which fractures are modeled as quadrilateral plates inserted into the structured matrix grid. EDFM captures the geometric details of fractures and meanwhile preserves the structured grid as background.…”

A numerical approach for pressure transient analysis of a vertical well with complex fractures

“…The large number of grids is required even if the aperture of the fracture is the smallest mesh scale. Another problem caused by the scale difference is the instability and divergence [12]. Although the equivalent seepage resistance method [13], which enlarges the aperture and reduces the permeability under the conditions of the same fracture flux and can be used, it is limited by the formation coefficient, fracture permeability and many other factors.…”

Numerical Simulation of Fluid-Solid Coupling in Fractured Porous Media with Discrete Fracture Model and Extended Finite Element Method

“…There exist several methods to simulate fluid flow in fractured porous media [6]. Warren and Root introduced the dual continuum concept to characterize naturally fractured reservoirs [7].…”