Comparison of emergency department crowding scores: a discrete-event simulation approach

Abstract

According to American College of Emergency Physicians, emergency department (ED) crowding occurs when the identified need for emergency services exceeds available resources for patient care in the ED, hospital, or both. ED crowding is a widely reported problem and several crowding scores are proposed to quantify crowding using hospital and patient data as inputs for assisting healthcare professionals in anticipating imminent crowding problems. Using data from a large academic hospital in North Carolina, we evaluate three crowding scores, namely, EDWIN, NEDOCS, and READI by assessing strengths and weaknesses of each score, particularly their predictive power. We perform these evaluations by first building a discrete-event simulation model of the ED, validating the results of the simulation model against observations at the ED under consideration, and utilizing the model results to investigate each of the three ED crowding scores under normal operating conditions and under two simulated outbreak scenarios in the ED. We conclude that, for this hospital, both EDWIN and NEDOCS prove to be helpful measures of current ED crowdedness, and both scores demonstrate the ability to anticipate impending crowdedness. Utilizing both EDWIN and NEDOCS scores in combination with the threshold values proposed in this work could provide a real-time alert for clinicians to anticipate impending crowding, which could lead to better preparation and eventually better patient care outcomes.

Methodological Approaches to Support Process Improvement in Emergency Departments: A Systematic Review

“…In fact, our review reports 12 papers (37.5%) evidencing the use of this technique in congested EDs. We noted that as Ahalt et al [185] discuss, simulation can serve as a way of measuring crowdedness, a metric that avoids efforts being expanded on unnecessary interventions and guides administrators towards the design of cost-effective solutions. On the other hand, Fitzgerald [186] described how simulation has propelled cultural changes in congested Australian EDs through providing fast and accurate predictions on change outcomes.…”

Emergency department resource optimisation for improved performance: a review

“…However, not much detail was provided about the model and experimental procedures. Estimated hourly patients' arrival rate (λ t ) per day (Ghanes et al 2014) Some studies aimed at optimising patient flow in EDs while minimising associated costs (Memari et al 2016;Ahalt et al 2018). Memari et al (2016) combined DES with queuing theory to develop the model.…”

Industrial Engineering for Healthcare Management – Example Lean Management and ICT Tools

“…Figure 3 and Figure 4 present a simplified model (Anylogic, 2019). Many authors, however, have developed more complex models dedicated to door-to-doctor (Ribeiro et al, 2016), overcrowding (Ahalt et al, 2018), impact of work pressure (Choi et al, 2019), and many others. Applying agent-based modelling for the analysed ED, one may design a model with three states of the agent (patient), i.e.…”