Comparison of Sporormiella dung fungal spores and oribatid mites as indicators of large herbivore presence: evidence from the Cuzco region of Peru

Abstract

The ability of sedimentary proxies (especially dung fungal spores) to reflect the past presence and density of large herbivores on a landscape has been receiving increasing scrutiny. Here we examine the Sporormiella spore record from a well-dated, multiproxy, highly organic sedimentary record from the small lake basin of Marcacocha in the Cuzco region of Peru. The basin, a wetland since ca. AD 1840, existed as a small lake for at least 4000 years prior. Previous work at Marcacocha has shown that changes in herbivore densities reflect the abundances of oribatid mites preserved in the lake sediments. This study tests the assumption that both the Sporormiella and the oribatid mite records responded in broadly the same way to changes in herbivore densities over the past 1200 years. Analysis reveals a very low covariance between concentrations of Sporormiella spores and the two major components of the oribatid mite assemblage: a single aquatic species of Hydrozetes and a less abundant, wider grouping comprising members of the mostly terrestrial superfamily Ceratozetoidea (referred to as the 'ceratozetoids'). Variations in the Hydrozetes assemblage clearly dovetail with known historical events, including the massive decline of indigenous and camelid populations following the collapse of the Inca Empire in the mid-sixteenth century. Comparison with other environmental proxies from the Marcacocha sequence, including diatoms and charophyte oospores, suggests that the ceratozetoids appear to reflect increasing terrestrialization. In contrast, although the Sporormiella record indicates the presence of livestock, it fails to register the major historical changes in herbivore presence, though reflects well episodes of lake-level lowering. In small lake settings, therefore, the use of Sporormiella to estimate the density of herbivores in the catchment might be considered a relatively blunt instrument when compared with some other indicators. Supporting Information: Appendix S1 Comparison of Sporormiella dung fungal spores and oribatid mites as indicators of large herbivore presence: evidence from the Cuzco region of Peru

Dung fungi as an indicator of large herbivore dynamics in peatlands

“…This is not the case at Moor House, where stocking levels are low and grazing impacts are limited. Disparities between CFS and non-pollen grazing indicators have also been observed in previous studies, although the reasons for this are not always clear (Ortiz et al 2016, Chepstow-Lusty et al 2019, while other records show strong and consistent correlations between palynological and fungal indicator values (e.g. Wood et al 2016).…”

Fungal biodiversity in Arctic paleoecosystems assessed by metabarcoding of lake sedimentary ancient DNA

“…Analyses of sedimentary deposits can reveal fungal community alterations and associated ecosystem changes over long periods of time. Investigating past fungal biodiversity changes by reconstructing paleoecosystems may generate insights regarding basal structural developments that are to date mostly overlooked in classical palynological approaches due to reliance on microscopic remains (Taylor and Osborn, 1996;Wood and Wilmshurst, 2013;Chepstow-Lusty et al, 2019). While molecular genetic methods are commonly used at present to investigate modern ecosystems (Heeger et al, 2018;Adamo et al, 2020), far fewer studies have been conducted on fungal biodiversity in paleoecosystems.…”

Environmental DNA and metagenomics of terrestrial mammals as keystone taxa of recent and past ecosystems

“…A commonly employed alternative is the use of proxy indicators, such as spores of coprophilous fungi, including those belonging to the Sporormiella ‐ Preussia species complex, Sordaria sp., Podospora sp., or Pilobolus sp. (reviewed by Perrotti & van Asperen 2019) or oribatid mites (Chepstow‐Lusty et al 2019). Morphological identification of spores of coprophilous fungi is complicated, and results may be error‐prone due to insufficient taxonomic resolution of spores and a lack of information on their biology, that is which fungal taxa are dependent solely on dung and therefore are useful indicators of herbivore biomass (Feranec et al 2011, Johnson et al 2015).…”

“…This means, for example that the youngest fossil of a species never represents the true last appearance – a principle known as the Signor–Lipps effect (Signor & Lipps 1982). In addition to direct evidence, palaeoecological studies can also utilise specific proxies for the presence of mammals, in particular dung fungi (Davies 2019, Goethals & Verschuren 2019) and parasites such as oribatid mites (Chepstow‐Lusty et al 2019).…”