“…Since the Y185F mutation increases the pKa for the acid-induced blue transition from 2.7 to 3.7, the O-like species which forms at higher pH cannot be attributed to this low-pH acid-induced blue form of Y18 5 F. However, the acidinduced blue membrane consists of a mixture of two forms containing all-trans and 13-cis isomers of retinal (Fischer & Oesterhelt, 1979;Mowery et al, 1979;Fahmy & Siebert, 1990). Although it is unlikely that the the O intermediate is equivalent to the acid-induced blue membrane (Smith & Mathies, 1985) as previously suggested (Moore et al, 1978;Edgerton et al, 1978;Lam et al, 1982), the possibility remains that the all-trans component of the acid-induced blue membrane (BM7) is similar to both the O intermediate and the O-like species we observe here. In fact, FTIR difference spectra for pH titration of wild-type bR between the purple and acid-induced blue form (Marrero & Rothschild, 1987) and more recent studies on light-adapted blue membrane (Fahmy & Siebert, 1990) reveal similarities in the vibrational spectra between the all-trans species formed at low pH and the O-like species we observe at higher pH in Y185F (He et al, 1993;Rath et al, 1993).…”