The
mechanisms whereby protein ions are released into the gas phase
from charged droplets during electrospray ionization (ESI) continue
to be controversial. Several pathways have been proposed. For native
ESI the charged residue model (CRM) is favored; it entails the liberation
of proteins via solvent evaporation to dryness. Unfolded proteins
likely follow the chain ejection model (CEM), which involves the gradual
expulsion of stretched-out chains from the droplet. According to the
ion evaporation model (IEM) ions undergo electrostatically driven
desorption from the droplet surface. The IEM is well supported for
small precharged species such as Na+. However, it is unclear
whether proteins can show IEM behavior as well. We examined this question
using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, mass spectrometry (MS),
and ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) in positive ion mode. Ubiquitin
was chosen as the model protein because of its structural stability
which allows the protein charge in solution to be controlled via pH
adjustment without changing the protein conformation. MD simulations
on small ESI droplets (3 nm radius) showed CRM behavior regardless
of the protein charge in solution. Surprisingly, many MD runs on larger
droplets (5.5 nm radius) culminated in IEM ejection of ubiquitin,
as long as the protein carried a sufficiently large positive solution
charge. MD simulations predicted that nonspecific salt adducts are
less prevalent for IEM-generated protein ions than for CRM products.
This prediction was confirmed experimentally. Also, collision cross
sections of MD structures were in good agreement with IMS data. Overall,
this work reveals that the CRM, CEM, and IEM all represent viable
pathways for generating gaseous protein ions during ESI. The IEM is
favored for proteins that are tightly folded and highly charged in
solution and for droplets in a suitable size regime.