V ertebrates make high-affinity antibodies to protect themselves against pathogenic organisms and their products. The generation of these antibodies requires the highly mutagenic enzyme activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) (1). AID deaminates dC to dU in ssDNA, and this mutation recruits additional error-prone repair to carry out somatic hypermutation (SHM) of the antibody variable (V) regions that encode the antigen-binding site, and class switch recombination (CSR), which allows those antigen binding sites to be expressed with different constant regions that mediate effector functions. However, it is still unclear how the genomic instability that is initiated by AID is restricted to only discrete parts of the Ig genes but spares the rest of the genome (2-4). In this issue of PNAS, Perlot et al. (5) provide a partial answer to this puzzle by identifying both sense and antisense transcripts of the V and switch (S) regions, both of which are targeted for mutation by AID; but they find only sense transcripts of the constant (C ) region, which is not targeted by AID (Fig. 1).The finding of antisense transcripts of the V and S regions in primary murine B cells is important because it addresses the unsolved problem of why both the lower (transcribed) and the upper (nontranscribed) strands of the V and S region DNA are highly mutated in mice and humans (6). This has been confusing because biochemical studies with semipurified AID (3, 4) and experiments in which AID was expressed in bacterial cells (7) have found AIDinduced mutations mostly on the upper strand of the targeted DNA. This suggested that something like the large transcription apparatus was protecting the lower strand, whereas the upper strand was accessible to AID ( Fig. 1). A number of explanations have been proposed for why both strands of the V and S regions are mutated in vivo, but not in vitro, such as differences between the mammalian and the bacterial RNA polymerases used in vitro (4), the accessibility of both strands in the supercoiled DNA at the edges of the transcription bubble (8), or ssDNA-binding replication protein A (RPA) participating with AID in mutation (4). Antisense transcription of the V and S regions provides an attractive, although not exclusive, alternative.Antisense transcripts had previously been observed in the V region of a human BurkittЈs lymphoma cell line (9), in S regions within the context of chromosomal translocations (10-12), and in pro-B cells during V(D)J recombination (13), but Perlot et al. (5) are the first to identify such transcripts from a rearranged V region in primary B cells. In the S regions, transcription of the C rich lower strand results in R-loops, where the very G rich nascent RNA hybridizes the template strand and prevents AID action while leaving the upper strand single stranded and accessible to AID (14). However, the G:C content of the V region does not predispose it to R-loop formation, and R-loops have not been found there.There is a considerable body of data that suggests that high rates o...