We have known for over 200 years that hydrogen undergoes rapid oxidation to water on Pt catalysts; yet the reaction mechanism remains unclear. Here, we report high temporal resolution measurements of the production rate of H 2 O from hydrogen oxidation catalysed by a Pt (111) single crystal surface with a known concentration of adsorbed oxygen atoms and a step density of approximately 0.002 ML. We obtain two rate constants describing the rise, and fall of the reaction rate between 350 and 470 K and compare our observations to modern ab initio predictions of the reaction rates in surface chemistry. Remarkably, a mechanism based on a standard set of elementary reaction steps with energies and barrier heights obtained from Density Functional Theory (DFT), predicts a rate that is four orders of magnitude smaller than observed experimentally. Furthermore, the theoretically predicted reaction rate follows first-order kinetics, whereas the experimental observations clearly show a second-order reaction. The theoretical predictions are robust -six different exchange-correlation functionals lead to similar predictions. We suggest that the reason for these disagreements is that the active sites of the catalyst and the associated elementary reactions have, so far, not been properly identified.