A polytrauma patient with a life-threatening condition is a quite demanding situation due to special considerations regarding the time, the way, and the sequence of the necessary procedures. Elastic intramedullary nails (EIN) could be used under these conditions for adult patients with humeral fractures requiring fixation. Here we present a case of a multi-segmental closed humerus fracture in a polytrauma patient treated by EIN. The general condition of the patient and the need for multiple surgical procedures required the selection of a minimally invasive and time-saving fixation technique. The patient's follow-up was uneventful with complete healing of the humeral fracture; the functional scores results are excellent at five years post operatively. A review of the literature revealed limited published cases of humeral fractures (128 patients) treated by EIN, despite the fact that the results are quite encouraging. Based on our results and the current literature, we believe that EIN could become an effective treatment choice for multi-level humerus fractures, especially in damage control surgery.