Conceptual models for Mental Distress among HIV-infected and uninfected individuals: A contribution to clinical practice and research in primary-health-care centers in Zambia

Abstract

BackgroundMental distress is common in primary care and overrepresented among Human Immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected individuals, but access to effective treatment is limited, particularly in developing countries. Explanatory models (EM) are contextualised explanations of illnesses and treatments framed within a given society and are important in understanding an individual's perspective on the illness. Although individual variations are important in determining help-seeking and treatment behaviour patterns, the ability to cope with an illness and quality of life, the role of explanatory models in shaping treatment preferences is undervalued. The aim was to identify explanatory models employed by HIV-infected and uninfected individuals and to compare them with those employed by local health care providers. Furthermore, we aimed to build a theoretical model linking the perception of mental distress to treatment preferences and coping mechanisms.MethodsQualitative investigation nested in a cross-sectional validation study of 28 (male and female) attendees at four primary care clinics in Lusaka, Zambia, between December 2008 and May 2009. Consecutive clinic attendees were sampled on random days and conceptual models of mental distress were examined, using semi-structured interviews, in order to develop a taxonomic model in which each category was associated with a unique pattern of symptoms, treatment preferences and coping strategies.ResultsMental distress was expressed primarily as somatic complaints including headaches, perturbed sleep and autonomic symptoms. Economic difficulties and interpersonal relationship problems were the most common causal models among uninfected individuals. Newly diagnosed HIV patients presented with a high degree of hopelessness and did not value seeking help for their symptoms. Patients not receiving anti-retroviral drugs (ARV) questioned their effectiveness and were equivocal about seeking help. Individuals receiving ARV were best adjusted to their status, expressed hope and valued counseling and support groups. Health care providers reported that 40% of mental distress cases were due to HIV infection.ConclusionsPatient models concerning mental distress are critical to treatment-seeking decisions and coping mechanisms. Mental health interventions should be further researched and prioritized for HIV-infected individuals.

Strengthening mental health systems in Zambia

“…Despite a global prevalence of 13%, inclusive of neurological and substance use disorders, mental disorders do not attract much attention [4]. The magnitude of mental disorders is amplified when comorbid with other disorders such as HIV/AIDS and coronary heart disease [5,6]. Projections for this disease burden were set to increase to about 15 per cent by 2020 and depression producing the second most significant disease burden across all age groups.…”

Fatigue and Sleep Disturbance Related to Perceived Stress in Chinese HIVPositive Individuals: A Mixed Methods Study

“…Many newly diagnosed PLWHA suffer from psychological stress like depression, anxiety, hopelessness, and suicidal ideation [8–11]. Perceived stresses also often present as physical symptoms such as headaches, sleep disturbances, fatigue, loss of appetite, and sexual difficulties [12]. …”

Contextualising women's mental distress and coping strategies in the time of AIDS: A rural South African case study

“…For example, Patel, Gwanzura, and Simunyu (1995) explored the ways in which primary health care patients in Zimbabwe account for their emotional distress, highlighting patients' emphasis on spiritual factors, particularly the stresses of being bewitched by others, as the most common explanation for distress. In Zambia, Chipimo, Tuba, and Fylkesnes (2011) and Aidoo and Harpham (2001) found that patients explained mental distress as a social and cultural experience rather than a medical one, defining it as "problems of the mind", and pinpointing social relationships, poverty and unemployment as primary causal factors. Interestingly the exception here was patients with AIDS, who, despite giving similar accounts of the social drivers of distress, tended to draw on more medical terminology in listing the symptoms of their distress, probably due to their greater familiarity with western health service settings.…”