Conceptual Models for Women’s Health Research: Reclaiming Menopause As an Exemplar of Nursing’s Contributions to Feminist Scholarship

Abstract

An examination of women’s transition through menopause provides a remarkable example of nursing’s contributions to feminist scholarship. The predominant biomedical model perpetuates the idea that menopause is a deficiency disease, whereas feminist and nurse scholars have deconstructed this paradigm and have reclaimed menopause as a part of midlife women’s developmental stage. We begin this chapter with a review of the birth of women’s health scholarship as it is the foundation for theory that undergirds feminist nursing research. We then discuss the tenets of feminist scholarship. The historical context of menopause is reviewed briefly to highlight the ways in which menopause was transformed from a normal physiological event to a disease. Using this as a backdrop, we reviewed nursing studies in two emerging bodies of knowledge. We reviewed 10 studies in the area of “women reclaiming menopause” and found that over all women believe the menopausal transition is a normal developmental stage. The second area of new research looks at “menopause across cultures.” The studies of Korean, Indian, and Thai women reviewed demonstrate that similar to other health issues, the experience of Western women cannot be universalized, and most important, researchers must take into consideration the social, political, economic, and cultural forces that impact women’s experience of the menopause transition.

Impact of a brief intervention on cervical health literacy: A waitlist control study with jailed women

“…But the overall flavor of the intervention was rooted in social and feminist theory. We sought to understand women's experiences within their social and political contexts, emphasizing: the role of romantic and sexual partnerships, family, and community in women's lives; the impact of race, class, and gender on specific health outcomes; and a rejection of status quo values and assumptions about women in general (Bourdieu, 1984, Andrist and MacPherson, 2001). …”

The Development of a Brief Jail-Based Cervical Health Promotion Intervention

“…We sought to empower women to tackle the range of their reproductive health needs and make the perception of a more “distant” problem of cervical cancer prevention a priority. The sexual health empowerment component of the intervention stemmed from a feminist perspective on health—understanding women’s experience within their social and political context, as well as a health-focused approach, not disease or illness focused (Andrist & MacPherson, 2001; Kelly & Bobo, 2004). This approach emphasized the context of romantic and sexual partnerships, family, and community in women’s lives; the role of the intersection of race-, class-, and gender-specific health outcomes; and rejection of status quo values and assumptions about women (Kelly & Bobo, 2004).…”

Feminist Perspectives and Practice With Young Women

“…In the area of women's health, the focus is on health, not disease or illness (Andrist & MacPherson, 2001;MacPherson, 1983;Raftos, Mannix, & Jackson, 1997). This perspective: (1) views women within the context of relationships, family, and community; (2) understands that class and race/ethnicity interact with gender to provide different outcomes for women of all ages and; (3) does not accept status quo values and assumptions about women (Harrison, 1993;Hughes, 1990).…”