Conceptualising cultural safety at an Indigenous-focused midwifery practice in Toronto, Canada: qualitative interviews with Indigenous and non-Indigenous clients

Abstract

ObjectiveCultural safety is an Indigenous concept that can improve how healthcare services are delivered to both Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples in Canada. This study explored how Indigenous and non-Indigenous clients at an urban, Indigenous-focused midwifery practice in Toronto, Canada (Seventh Generation Midwives Toronto, SGMT) conceptualised and experienced culturally safe care.Design and settingInterviews were conducted with former clients of SGMT as a part of a larger evaluation of the practice. Participants were purposefully recruited. Interviews were transcribed and analysed thematically using an iterative, consensus-based approach and a critical, naturalistic, and decolonising lens.ParticipantsSaturation was reached after 20 interviews (n=9 Indigenous participants, n=11 non-Indigenous participants).ResultsThree domains of cultural safety emerged. Each domain included several themes: Relationships and Communication (respect and support for choices; personalised and continuous relationships with midwives; and being different from past experiences); Sharing Knowledge and Practice (feeling informed about the basics of pregnancy, birth, and the postpartum period; and having access to Indigenous knowledge and protocols), and Culturally Safe Spaces (feeling at home in practice; and having relationships interconnected with the physical space). While some ideas were shared across groups, the distinctions between the Indigenous and non-Indigenous participants were prominent.ConclusionThe Indigenous participants conceptualised cultural safety in ways that highlight the survival and resurgence of Indigenous values, understandings, and approaches in cities like Toronto, and affirm the need for Indigenous midwives. The non-Indigenous participants conceptualised cultural safety with both congruence, illuminating Black-Indigenous community solidarities in cultural safety, and divergence, demonstrating the potential of Indigenous spaces and Indigenous-focused midwifery care to also benefit midwifery clients of white European descent. We hope that the positive impacts documented here motivate evaluators and healthcare providers to work towards a future where ‘cultural safety’ becomes a standard of care.

Health Policy as a Barrier to First Nations Peoples’ Access to Cancer Screening

“…Our results are in line with those of others who have emphasized the critical importance of enacting specific policies and procedures aimed at promoting increased cultural safety ( Allan and Smylie 2015 ; Baba 2013 ; Brascoupé and Waters 2009 ). Culturally competent healthcare has the potential to improve health disparities by increasing awareness of and addressing root causes such as structural racism and discrimination ( Brooks-Cleator et al 2018 ; Churchill et al 2017 ). Cultural competency is indisputably important for healthcare providers who interact with Indigenous peoples on a daily basis; it is equally important among those contributing to policy development and implementation (e.g., RCP/CCO Leadership).…”

Access to ultrasound imaging: A qualitative study in two northern, remote, Indigenous communities in Canada

“…Health disparities secondary to colonial legacies have been documented in Canada as well as other countries such as Australia, New Zealand, and the USA, with colonisation adversely affecting physical, social, emotional, and mental health and well-being of Indigenous peoples [ 40 ]. It is critical for health systems to ensure cultural safety throughout the planning, delivery, and evaluation of medical imaging services in a way which supports Indigenous peoples’ needs and fosters ethical and respectful relationships between patients and providers [ 41 , 42 ].…”

Indigenous approaches to health and wellness leadership: A BC First Nations perspective

“…43 Ensuring that health services are free of racism and discrimination and are places where First Nations people feel safe is an important area of work in progress in BC. 44,46 “If we pray in a circle, and face the eagle feather placed on the drum in the centre of the circle, we each see feather differently even though we are looking at the same thing. Together, our perspectives contribute to the full perspective of that drum and feather in a way a single view does not capture.” (teaching from Sye x wáliya, Skwxwú7mesh Úxwumixw)This teaching recognizes the strengths BC First Nations knowledge, medicines, and healing practices alongside mainstream health knowledge and medicine.…”