Concussion Care Practices and Utilization of Evidence-Based Guidelines in the Evaluation and Management of Concussion: A Survey of New England Emergency Departments

Abstract

Evidence-based clinical practice guidelines can facilitate proper evaluation and management of concussions in the emergency department (ED), often the initial and primary point of contact for concussion care. There is no universally adopted set of guidelines for concussion management, and extant evidence suggests that there may be variability in concussion care practices and limited application of clinical practice guidelines in the ED. This study surveyed EDs throughout New England to examine current practices of concussion care and utilization of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines in the evaluation and management of concussions. In 2013, a 32-item online survey was e-mailed to 149/168 EDs throughout New England (Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine). Respondents included senior administrators asked to report on their EDs use of clinical practice guidelines, neuroimaging decision-making, and discharge instructions for concussion management. Of the 72/78 respondents included, 35% reported absence of clinical practice guidelines, and 57% reported inconsistency in the type of guidelines used. Practitioner preference guided neuroimaging decision-making for 57%. Although 94% provided written discharge instructions, there was inconsistency in the recommended time frame for follow-up care (13% provided no specific time frame), the referral specialist to be seen (25% did not recommend any specialist), and return to activity instructions were inconsistent. There is much variability in concussion care practices and application of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines in the evaluation and management of concussions in New England EDs. Knowledge translational efforts will be critical to improve concussion management in the ED setting.

Benefits of applying for hospital accreditation: The perspective of staff

“…According to the health care accreditation assessments, Jordan's hospital management system is oriented towards enabling hospitals to flourish in their organisational capacity (A'aqoulah, Kuyini, Ajlouni, Saif, & Al-Raoush, 2016). Conversely, it is also responsible for ensuring health care safety, based on primary facilities of organisational services (Stern et al, 2017). Accreditation has been defined as:…”

Healthcare providers’ attitudes and behaviours related to paediatric mild traumatic brain injury: results from the 2014 DocStyles survey

“…To do this well, healthcare providers need knowledge, decision-support tools, and other resources to support the care of their patients (2). Yet, recent studies indicate that healthcare providers may not use available practise guidelines and resources (3,4). A 2013 survey of emergency department physicians found that 35% of physicians did not use evidence-based clinical practise guidelines to manage mTBI (3).…”

“…Yet, recent studies indicate that healthcare providers may not use available practise guidelines and resources (3,4). A 2013 survey of emergency department physicians found that 35% of physicians did not use evidence-based clinical practise guidelines to manage mTBI (3). Another survey of paediatricians in Illinois found that only 14.6% used mTBI guidelines in their practise (4).…”

The impact of patient characteristics on nurse practitioners’ assessment and management of adolescent concussion

“…A recent regional study of pediatric providers reported that over half did not use guidelines in managing pediatric concussion patients (Itriyeva et al, 2016). Another recently published regional survey of New England emergency departments indicated that the majority reported having no concussion clinical practice guidelines (35%) or inconsistency in the type of concussion guidelines used (57%; Stern et al, 2016).…”