Concussion Recovery Time Among High School and Collegiate Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Background Concussion diagnosis and management is made through the clinical exam using assessment tools that include self-report symptomatology, postural control, and cognitive evaluations. The specific timing of concussion resolution varies between individuals. However, despite a lack of research in concussion recovery, it is widely accepted that the majority of young adults will recover in 7–10 days, with youth athletes taking longer. Objectives The purpose of this review is to directly compare the recovery duration among high school and collegiate athletes on symptom reports and cognitive assessments following concussion. Data Sources Data were collected from a literature search comprising high school or college athletes only. This included studies (n = 6) that reported symptom or cognitive performance recovery to the exact day. Results High school athletes self-reported symptom recovery at 15 days compared with 6 days in collegiate athletes. Both college and high school athletes showed cognitive recovery at similar rates of 5 and 7 days. Limitations This review only included articles that were directly related to concussed high school or college athletes. Additionally, athletes in the high school and college setting typically receive a battery of neurocognitive tests that may not be as sensitive or as comprehensive as a full neuropsychological exam. Conclusion The review finds that neurocognitive recovery rates are similar among high school and college athletes, while symptom reporting shows longer recovery time points in high school than in college. Implications of Key Findings An individualized and stepwise concussion management plan is important for proper concussion recovery regardless of age.

High Baseline Postconcussion Symptom Scores and Concussion Outcomes in Athletes

“…Finally, the no-symptoms group was slightly younger than the high-symptoms group. However, in contrast to some studies that suggested younger athletes performed worse on neurocognitive testing 31 and that high school students were symptomatic for a longer time than collegiate athletes after injury, 32 our findings did not support this pattern, which may indicate that baseline symptoms overshadow the contribution of age.…”

What is the difference in concussion management in children as compared with adults? A systematic review

“…In general, age appears to be an important variable, and studies not limited to SRC show symptom resolution among high school athletes taking longer than collegiate athletes 129. These have led to more conservative recommendations for RTSp in youth athletes, but specific criteria are lacking.…”

TBI and Concussions in Student Athletes: How do Severity of Injury, Age, and Gender Influence Recovery

“…Additional studies have found that high school athletes report longer times for recovery from symptoms compared to college athletes; 15 days for high school athletes and 6 days of collegiate athletes (Williams et al 2015). In contrast, college and high school athletes showed cognitive recovery at similar rates of 5 and 7 days, respectively.…”