Conductorless singing group: a particular kind of self-managed team?

Abstract

Purpose: Coordination of group activity is rarely more important than in a singing group that has no designated conductor. This paper aims to explore the group dynamics in an 11-man singing group whose members, all over 60, have without exception occupied senior leadership positions in their working careers. The study arose because responses to a wider research study revealed interesting perceptions of leadership issues in the group. Design/methodology/approach: All the members participated in semi-structured interviews and interpretative phenomenological analysis of the responses was used to process the responses. This enabled the identification of practices that support the group's success and illustrated how this group of practiced "leaders" respond to a (relatively) conductorless situation. Findings: It was confirmed that the group exhibits several characteristics of self-managed teams and string quartets. All members felt empowered to take a lead, although their backgrounds might have predisposed them to take such initiatives anyway. But the longserving female accompanist is, by virtue inter alia of her superior musicianship, which appears to overcome any gender bias, in many respects the de facto leader. In performance, the singers synchronize their singing in response to cues from each other, but this could work better if given more specific attention. Originality/value: Whereas conducted choirs have been extensively studied, such a selfmanaged group of amateur singers, all of whom are accustomed to leading in their working careers, has apparently not been studied. This study sheds some light on techniques for overcoming the challenges of creating quality performance in such a group and insights for similar groups, not necessarily musical, are identified.

Interperformer coordination in piano-singing duo performances: phrase structure and empathy impact

“…In this study, we conceptualized musical leadership as manifested in musicians’ head-motion. Such a tendency to anticipate or lag somebody else’s head motion is certainly not a comprehensive view of leadership, which is studied often in terms of social roles (Garrido & Requena, 2015 ; King, 2006 ; Lim, 2014 ; Page-Shipp et al, 2018 ) rather than body motion’s phase synchronicity. Future mixed studies might further advance our understanding of leadership in ensembles, by analysing patterns in verbal social interactions during rehearsals in combination with sound and body motion synchronization.…”

Living in Artistic Career: The Role of Job Crafting towards Work Identity for Musicians

“…A professional worker will most likely derive work identity from the organization-related activities and interactions. A previous study reported that a member of a singing group concluded to have identity as organizer of the teamsince the person committed to managing the team's activities (Page-Shipp et al, 2018). In terms of team performance, Boerner et al (2004) suggested that orchestral musicians need to be cooperative as team players, in order to give artistic quality to the music.…”