Objective
We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to examine the
accuracy of bedside ultrasound for confirmation of central venous catheter
position and exclusion of pneumothorax compared to chest radiography.
Data Sources
PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials,
reference lists, conference proceedings and ClinicalTrials.gov
Study Selection
Articles and abstracts describing the diagnostic accuracy of bedside
ultrasound compared with chest radiography for confirmation of central
venous catheters in sufficient detail to reconstruct 2×2 contingency
tables were reviewed. Primary outcomes included the accuracy of confirming
catheter positioning and detecting a pneumothorax. Secondary outcomes
included feasibility, inter-rater reliability, and efficiency to complete
bedside ultrasound confirmation of central venous catheter position.
Data Extraction
Investigators abstracted study details including research design and
sonographic imaging technique to detect catheter malposition and
procedure-related pneumothorax. Diagnostic accuracy measures included pooled
sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio, and negative likelihood
ratio.
Data Synthesis
15 studies with 1553 central venous catheter placements were
identified with a pooled sensitivity and specificity of catheter malposition
by ultrasound of 0.82 [0.77, 0.86] and 0.98 [0.97,
0.99] respectively. The pooled positive and negative likelihood
ratios of catheter malposition by ultrasound were 31.12 [14.72,
65.78] and 0.25 [0.13, 0.47]. The sensitivity and
specificity of ultrasound for pneumothorax detection was nearly 100%
in the participating studies. Bedside ultrasound reduced mean central venous
catheter confirmation time by 58.3 minutes. Risk of bias and clinical
heterogeneity in the studies were high.
Conclusions
Bedside ultrasound is faster than radiography at identifying
pneumothorax after central venous catheter insertion. When a central venous
catheter malposition exists, bedside ultrasound will identify four out of
every five earlier than chest radiography.