Conflict resolution in anaesthesia: systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundConflict is a significant and recurrent problem in most modern healthcare systems. Given its ubiquity, effective techniques to manage or resolve conflict safely are required.ObjectiveThis review focuses on conflict resolution interventions for improvement of patient safety through understanding and applying/teaching conflict resolution skills that critically depend on communication and improvement of staff members’ ability to voice their concerns.MethodsWe used the Population-Intervention-Comparator-Outcome model to outline our methodology. Relevant English language sources for both published and unpublished papers up to February 2018 were sourced across five electronic databases: the Cochrane Library, EMBASE, MEDLINE, SCOPUS and Web of Science.ResultsAfter removal of duplicates, 1485 studies were screened. Six articles met the inclusion criteria with a total sample size of 286 healthcare worker participants. Three training programmes were identified among the included studies: (A) crisis resource management training; (B) the Team Strategies and Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety (TeamSTEPPS) training; and (C) the two-challenge rule (a component of TeamSTEPPS), and two studies manipulating wider team behaviours. Outcomes reported included participant reaction and observer rating of conflict resolution, speaking up or advocacy-inquiry behaviours. Study results were inconsistent in showing benefits of interventions.ConclusionThe evidence for training to improve conflict resolution in the clinical environment is sparse. Novel methods that seek to influence wider team behaviours may complement traditional interventions directed at individuals.

Factors influence anaesthesia technician work in intensive care unit (ICU): Qualitative study

“…It is considered to be one part of threatening patient safety. 2 Professional communication with the working team is an important factor that influences healthcare professionals. In general, people normally tend to work in an environment where they are liked and have good communication and social support with their colleagues and supervisor.…”

“…1 In such an environment, ensuring patient safety requires a multidisciplinary team who should cooperate effectively and share their knowledge and skills to achieve the aimed target. 2 Anaesthesia technicians are part of the ICU medical team responsible for collaborative medical management to patients. Their job is taking care and troubleshooting the ventilators , nebulizer treatments and airway clearance measures which are normally done by the respiratory therapists (RTs) in other countries/hospitalist because of how scant the RTs in Libya.…”

The flip side of speaking up: a new model to facilitate positive responses to speaking up in the operating theatre

“…5e7 Proposed interventions include graded assertiveness or the two-challenge rule. 8 We propose that speaking up should be viewed as a shared responsibility between the speaker (i.e. the person speaking up) and the receiver (i.e.…”