The base excision repair DNA glycosylases, EcoNth and hNTHL1, are
homologous, with reported overlapping yet different substrate specificities. The
catalytic amino acid residues are known and are identical between the two
enzymes although the exact structures of the substrate binding pockets remain to
be determined. We sought to explore the sequence basis of substrate differences
using a phylogeny-based design of site-directed mutations. Mutations were made
for each enzyme in the vicinity of the active site and we examined these
variants for glycosylase and lyase activity. Single turnover kinetics were done
on a subgroup of these, comparing activity on two lesions, 5,6-dihydrouracil and
5,6-dihydrothymine, with different opposite bases. We report that wild type
hNTHL1 and EcoNth are remarkably alike with respect to the specificity of the
glycosylase reaction, and although hNTHL1 is a much slower enzyme than EcoNth,
the tighter binding of hNTHL1 compensates, resulting in similar
kcat/Kd values
for both enzymes with each of the substrates tested. For the hNTHL1 variant
Gln287Ala, the specificity for substrates positioned opposite G is lost, but not
that of substrates positioned opposite A, suggesting a discrimination role for
this residue. The EcoNth Thr121 residue influences enzyme binding to DNA, as
binding is significantly reduced with the Thr121Ala variant. Finally, we present
evidence that hNTHL1 Asp144, unlike the analogous EcoNth residue Asp44, may be
involved in resolving the glycosylase transition state.