The effect of the protonation state
of glutamic acid on its translocation
through cyclic peptide nanotubes (CPNs) was assessed by using molecular
dynamics (MD) simulations. Anionic (GLU−), neutral zwitterionic
(GLU0), and cationic (GLU+) forms of glutamic acid were selected as
three different protonation states for an analysis of energetics and
diffusivity for acid transport across a cyclic decapeptide nanotube.
Based on the solubility-diffusion model, permeability coefficients
for the three protonation states of the acid were calculated and compared
with experimental results for CPN-mediated glutamate transport through
CPNs. Potential of mean force (PMF) calculations reveal that, due
to the cation-selective nature of the lumen of CPNs, GLU–,
so-called glutamate, shows significantly high free energy barriers,
while GLU+ displays deep energy wells and GLU0 has mild free energy
barriers and wells inside the CPN. The considerable energy barriers
for GLU– inside CPNs are mainly attributed to unfavorable interactions
with DMPC bilayers and CPNs and are reduced by favorable interactions
with channel water molecules through attractive electrostatic interactions
and hydrogen bonding. Unlike the distinct PMF curves, position-dependent
diffusion coefficient profiles exhibit comparable frictional behaviors
regardless of the charge status of three protonation states due to
similar confined environments imposed by the lumen of the CPN. The
calculated permeability coefficients for the three protonation states
clearly demonstrate that glutamic acid has a strong protonation state
dependence for its transport through CPNs, as determined by the energetics
rather than the diffusivity of the protonation state. In addition,
the permeability coefficients also imply that GLU– is unlikely
to pass through a CPN due to the high energy barriers inside the CPN,
which is in disagreement with experimental measurements, where a considerable
amount of glutamate permeating through the CPN was detected. To resolve
the discrepancy between this work and the experimental observations,
several possibilities are proposed, including a large concentration
gradient of glutamate between the inside and outside of lipid vesicles
and bilayers in the experiments, the glutamate activity difference
between our MD simulations and experiments, an overestimation of energy
barriers due to the artifacts imposed in MD simulations, and/or finally
a transformation of the protonation state from GLU– to GLU0
to reduce the energy barriers. Overall, our study demonstrates that
the protonation state of glutamic acid has a strong effect on the
transport of the acid and suggests a possible protonation state change
for glutamate permeating through CPNs.