Consensus Recommendations to NCCIH from Research Faculty in a Transdisciplinary Academic Consortium for Complementary and Integrative Health and Medicine

Abstract

Background: This commentary presents the most impactful, shared priorities for research investment across the licensed complementary and integrative health (CIH) disciplines according to the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care (ACCAHC). These are (1) research on whole disciplines; (2) costs; and (3) building capacity within the disciplines' universities, colleges, and programs. The issue of research capacity is emphasized.Discussion: ACCAHC urges expansion of investment in the development of researchers who are graduates of CIH programs, particularly those with a continued association with accredited CIH schools. To increase capacity of CIH discipline researchers, we recommend National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) to (1) continue and expand R25 grants for education in evidence-based healthcare and evidence-informed practice at CIH schools; (2) work to limit researcher attrition from CIH institutions by supporting career development grants for clinicians from licensed CIH fields who are affiliated with and dedicated to continuing to work in accredited CIH schools; (3) fund additional stand-alone grants to CIH institutions that already have a strong research foundation, and collaborate with appropriate National Institutes of Health (NIH) institutes and centers to create infrastructure in these institutions; (4) stimulate higher percentages of grants to conventional centers to require or strongly encourage partnership with CIH institutions or CIH researchers based at CIH institutions, or give priority to those that do; (5) fund research conferences, workshops, and symposia developed through accredited CIH schools, including those that explore best methods for studying the impact of whole disciplines; and (6) following the present NIH policy of giving priority to new researchers, we urge NCCIH to give a marginal benefit to grant applications from CIH clinician-researchers at CIH academic/research institutions, to acknowledge that CIH concepts require specialized expertise to translate to conventional perspectives.Summary: We commend NCCIH for its previous efforts to support high-quality research in the CIH disciplines. As NCCIH develops its 2016–2020 strategic plan, these recommendations to prioritize research based on whole disciplines, encourage collection of outcome data related to costs, and further support capacity-building within CIH institutions remain relevant and are a strategic use of funds that can benefit the nation's health.

Values Align for Researching Whole Systems: A Reflective Overview of the Special Issue

“…19 An organized effort to convince the largest funding entity for complementary and integrative health to prioritize ''researching the way we practice'' in multimodal integrative clinical has produced limited response. 20 Can it be that former WSR researchers have become pragmatic trialists-a direction that their ranks arguably fostered? Or are they seeking to approximate capturing the whole through mixed methods research?…”

Naturopathic Research: Prevalent, Relevant, But Largely Hidden in Plain Sight

“…In Australia, for instance, they attract more federal government funding than physiotherapists, pharmacists, psychologists, chiropractors, nurses, and osteopaths, 1 and naturopathic doctors have been active in National Institute of Health grants. 2 Despite these successes, naturopathy is also the only licensed health profession internationally that does not have its own dedicated journal indexed with the National Library of Medicine. This special focus issue represents the first PubMed indexed collation of research by naturopaths and about naturopathy.…”

Society for Acupuncture Research 2019: Putting the Whole Acupuncturist Back Together Again—To Set Them to Work!

“…Key professional and academic organizations have advocated-with only marginal responsefor ''researching the way we practice.'' 8 The call is for whole systems research. Dissent has been registered more vociferously abroad.…”