Consequences of Working in Eldercare during Organizational Changes and Cut Backs While Education and Clinical Supervision Was Provided: A Mixed Methods Study

Abstract

Background: Reorganization and downsizing can disrupt a competent staff and conflicts can arise between what the employee is being asked to do and their knowledge and competences. Reduced job satisfaction among nursing home staff with increased workload and strain can occur. Aim and Objectives: The aim was to investigate the organizational climate and prevalence of burnout symptoms among caregivers over time in three Swedish nursing homes (NH I-III) undergoing organizational changes, while education and clinical supervision were provided. Design: The study design combines qualitative and quantitative methods in a longitudinal two-year follow-up project in NH I-III. Methods: Support through education and clinical supervision was provided for caregivers only at NH I and NH II. At NH I-III caregiver self-assessments and interviews were completed and analysed three different times. Results: NH I revealed improvement and increased innovation over time, while NH II showed a decline with no ability to implement new knowledge. NH III retained a more status quo. Conclusions: Organizational changes and cutbacks, occurring at different times, appeared to cause major stress and frustration among the three personnel groups. They felt * Corresponding author. B. Fläckman et al. 814 guilty about not meeting their perceived obligations, seemed to have lost pride in their work but kept struggling. The changes seemed to overshadow attempts to improve working conditions through education and clinical supervision initially. Implications for practice: It will be important to learn from reorganizations and the consequences they will have for the staff and quality of care. Important topics for future research are to study financial cutbacks and changes in organizational processes in care of older people to be able to develop a more person centered care for older people.

Gaming the system to care for patients: a focused ethnography in Norwegian public home care

“…As findings show, many patients are grateful for any help they receive and place few demands on nurses; these patients are vulnerable to unfair resource allocation. Furthermore, if nurses spend their energy and focus on manipulating the system rather than caring for the patients, it may cause suffering for patients and burnout in nurses [48, 72]. Patients may also be at risk for burnout if they constantly adjust their behavior to ease nurses’ work.…”

“…Even though healthcare personnel are obligated by law to provide professionally sound and compassionate services, less than 40% of community nurses report having enough time to safeguard patients’ needs for caring, social contact, and companionship [15]. Being unable to fulfill these obligations can cause stress, frustration, guilt, and loss of pride in giving good care [48]. Formalized and task-oriented services can lead to nurses’ professional judgement being overlooked in the healthcare organization, and NPRs, caring and individualized care may suffer as a result.…”

Nurse assistants' experiences and knowledge of how they create a meaningful daily life for older persons receiving municipal home healthcare

“…This means that the NAs must assure that the care they perform follows the guidelines [12]. However, they have to perform their work in an elderly care system that faces several challenges, for example, an increasing number of older persons with multiple illnesses who live at home [13], an increasing number of personnel on sick leave and a strained economy in the municipality [12, 14]. In addition, demands for high quality and organisational changes raise new requirements such as the implementation of person‐centred care (PCC) and create a meaningful life for the person [15, 16].…”

Work stress and burnout among physicians and nurses in Internal and Emergency Departments

“…Reorganizations and downsizing have become an increasingly common stressful event in the health-care system and have been associated with a high degree of depression, anxiety and emotional exhaustion). [6][7][8] Falling reimbursement, downsizing, budget cuts, layoffs, reorganization efforts, and rising expenses, especially without rewarding systems and any perspective of career progression, all usually result in three things more work intensity, more demands on time, more job complexity. 9 More work added to less rewards means dissatisfaction.…”