Constitutive Modeling of Brain Tissue: Current Perspectives

Abstract

Modeling the mechanical response of the brain has become increasingly important over the past decades. Although mechanical stimuli to the brain are small under physiological conditions, mechanics plays a significant role under pathological conditions including brain development, brain injury, and brain surgery. Well calibrated and validated constitutive models for brain tissue are essential to accurately simulate these phenomena. A variety of constitutive models have been proposed over the past three decades, but no general consensus on these models exists. Here, we provide a comprehensive and structured overview of state-of-the-art modeling of the brain tissue. We categorize the different features of existing models into time-independent, time-dependent, and history-dependent contributions. To model the time-independent, elastic behavior of the brain tissue, most existing models adopt a hyperelastic approach. To model the time-dependent response, most models either use a convolution integral approach or a multiplicative decomposition of the deformation gradient. We evaluate existing constitutive models by their physical motivation and their practical relevance. Our comparison suggests that the classical Ogden model is a well-suited phenomenological model to characterize the time-independent behavior of the brain tissue. However, no consensus exists for mechanistic, physics-based models, neither for the time-independent nor for the time-dependent response. We anticipate that this review will provide useful guidelines for selecting the appropriate constitutive model for a specific application and for refining, calibrating, and validating future models that will help us to better understand the mechanical behavior of the human brain.

Mechanical characterization of human brain tumors from patients and comparison to potential surgical phantoms

“…Most constitutive models of the brain require assumptions about viscosity [36], and it has been recently demonstrated that both viscous and elastic properties of hydrogels can regulate cell behavior [54]. …”

Materials and technologies for soft implantable neuroprostheses

“…By contrast, MRE shows fluidization with age (and that female brains are more elastic than male brains) 65 . Such discrepancies are not uncommon in this field and are widely discussed 22,47,51,65,66 . They could emanate from different preparative procedures of the tissue, time and length scales, as well as modes of deformation, and the change of properties between in vivo and in vitro measurements, among other possible factors.…”

“…They could emanate from different preparative procedures of the tissue, time and length scales, as well as modes of deformation, and the change of properties between in vivo and in vitro measurements, among other possible factors. Improved microscopic models of brain tissue might help to resolve these differences in the future 49,66 .…”

Syringe-injectable mesh electronics integrate seamlessly with minimal chronic immune response in the brain

“…Specifically, the mesh has all size features comparable to or smaller than neuron soma and bending stiffness values of ∼0.1 nN·m, comparable to a 150-μm-thick brain tissue slice (i.e., the same as the overall implanted open mesh diameter), ∼0.4 nN·m (27,28) and orders of magnitude smaller (more flexible) than conventional probes (14,29,30). Herein, we present systematic time-dependent histology studies of the mesh electronics/brain-tissue interface obtained from tissue sections perpendicular (horizontal slices) and parallel (sagittal slices) to the long axis of probes, as well as time-dependent measurements obtained from horizontal tissue sections containing the cross-sections Significance Seamless integration of electrical probes within neural tissue could substantially enhance their impact and open up new opportunities in neuroscience research through electronic therapeutics.…”