Constructing agri-food for finance: startups, venture capital and food future imaginaries

Abstract

Over the past decade, investments in agricultural and food technology startups have grown to previously unknown dimensions. Mushrooming agri-food tech startups that promise to solve critical issues in the agri-food system through technological innovation are increasingly perceived as an attractive new investment opportunity for venture capitalists and investors. This paper investigates how digital agri-food technologies are narrated, constructed, and promoted for financial investment. Through qualitative content analysis of agri-food tech industry reports, articles, and commentaries we trace the logic, rationales, and narratives of this most recent investment rush, and reveal its immanent techno-finance fixes. We conceptualize the agri-food imaginaries produced within the agri-food tech discourse as financialized imaginaries, and argue that they are specifically tailored to construct, incentivize, and legitimize this new agri-food tech space for financial investment. In their attempt to raise money from investors, venture capital firms further fuel this development by discursively creating an ‘agri-food tech investment rush’—similar to the land and gold rushes of the past. Investments in agri-food tech startups, however, are presented to investors as both a profitable investment opportunity as well as a moral obligation, allowing for food production to cope with neo-malthusian and environmental threats. This paper contributes to our understanding of digitization as a socio-technical project, which includes the active envisioning and promotion of desirable agri-food futures.

The Impact of the Digital Economy on Food System Resilience: Insights from a Study across 190 Chinese Towns

“…More strikingly, the creation of online content in the UK in 2000 has had a substantial, enduring effect on regional productivity levels 16 years later [94]. Digitization is a social technology project, and it actively promotes the ideal future of agricultural food [95]. We believe that the digital economy could affect the resilience of food systems in other regions.…”

Rebalance power and strengthen farmers’ position in the EU food system? A CDA of the Farm to Fork Strategy

“…This constructs an agri-food imaginary with venture capitalists and private investors portrayed as saviours, morally obliged to invest for protecting the food system from 'neo-Malthusian' and ecological threats while simultaneously feeding a growing population (Sippel and Dolinga 2022). In this era of bio-economy transitions, the EU agri-food industry is going beyond food production innovations towards commodifying farmers' knowledge, agricultural data (Grain 2021), ecosystem services, and natural resources (ECVC 2022).…”

“…The new Common Agricultural Policy, implemented in January 2023, aims for operationalizing the F2F Strategy during the period 2023-2027 by focusing on ten key objectives ranging from environmental and ecological aspects to improving farmers' competitiveness, income, and position in the EU food system transition (EC 2022a). Sippel and Dolinga (2022) have pointed out that the global agri-food transition discourse is creating sociotechnical imaginaries 1 specifically for legitimizing financial investment for transforming food production into a hightech industry. The EU's food system transition policies are also endorsing this trend.…”

How agriculture performs urbanity: connecting urbanization and socio-practical shifts in farming cultures

“…Considering the limited economic opportunities in remote areas, these correlations between rurality and agriculture might not be especially surprising. Contemporary 'Western' agriculture, however, is at the forefront of developing and applying complex technological solutions linked to globalized industries and finance (Sippel & Dolinga 2023), a configuration which increasingly reshapes the look and routines of farming. Societal digitization (cf.…”