“…25 The reactivities of the gas-phase NbS + cation with some small molecules, such as CO and CO 2 have been investigated, 26–28 and several bi-nuclear complexes containing Nb 2 S 4 4+ cores have been reported as precatalysts in the reaction of HER. Compared to the relatively less attention paid to Nb x S y clusters gained in HER, Mo x S y clusters have been widely used as promising HER catalysts, 29 such as Mo 2 S 12 , 30 Mo 3 S 4 , 31–35 Mo 3 S 7 , 36,37 Mo 3 S 13 , 38–41 and Mo 6 S 8 . 42 The current research on Nb x S y clusters mainly focuses on the mono/bi-nuclear Nb x S y clusters in the gas phase, and multi-nuclear Nb x S y clusters are rarely reported, especially in the HER study.…”