The allelic ladder component of genotyping systems is of utmost importance for accurate allele designation and sizing precision quality assurances by capillary electrophoresis. The production process for ladders also demands adherence to specific technical criteria in order to pass as a reliable profiling system. The conventional methodology for ladder production includes allele isolation by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis purification followed by amplification of each allele isolate using the polymerase chain reaction. Alternatively, the allele cloning approach has long been promoted as being less labor intensive, higher throughput, and more suitable for long‐term storage of the allele isolates. In this study, we present a workflow to produce a short tandem repeat allelic ladder using a cloning approach. We identified the key factors that may impact the quality of the ladder and provide recommendations to resolve these challenges. In this study, 143 alleles from 10 Y‐chromosome short tandem repeat loci were cloned and amplified individually from plasmid extracts. Amplicons were assessed using quality assurance criteria for selection of polymerase chain reaction products and dilution factors to produce, first, a balanced ladder for each locus, and then a final ladder compiled from each individual locus ladder. The final product was suitable for forensic applications.