Content Validation of a Practice-Based Work Capacity Assessment Instrument Using ICF Core Sets

Abstract

Purpose A shift from providing long-term disability benefits to promoting work reintegration of people with remaining work capacity in many countries requires new instruments for work capacity assessments. Recently, a practice-based instrument addressing biopsychosocial aspects of functioning, the Social Medical Work Capacity instrument (SMWC), was developed. Our aim was to examine the content validity of the SMWC using ICF core sets. Methods First, we conducted a systematic search to identify relevant ICF core sets for the working age population. Second the content of these core sets were mapped to assess the relevance and comprehensiveness of the SMWC. Next, we compared the content of the SMWC with the ICF-core sets. Results Two work-related core sets and 31 disease-specific core sets were identified. The SMWC and the two work-related core sets overlap on 47 categories. Compared to the work-related core sets, the Body Functions and Activities and Participation are well represented in the new instrument, while the component Environmental factors is under-represented. Compared to the disease-specific core sets, items related to the social and domestic environmental factors are under-represented, while the SMWC included work-related factors complementary to the ICF. Conclusion The SMWC content seems relevant, but could be more comprehensive for the purpose of individual work capacity assessments. To improve assessing relevant biopsychosocial aspects, it is recommended to extend the instrument by adding personal and environmental (work-and social-related) factors as well as a more tailored use of the SMWC for assessing work capacity of persons with specific diseases or underlying illness.

Swedish managers’ experience-based understanding of the Capacity to work in employees with Common Mental Disorders: a Focus Group Study

“…To further understanding of CMDs and their impact on capacity to work, epidemiological studies in both clinical and working populations should be performed. However, that is currently problematic, because of the lack of instruments that measure the particularities of work capacity in people with CMDs [ 45 , 46 ] as well as the lack of instruments that take a comprehensive biopsychosocial approach to the individual with CMD [ 47 ].…”

The Assessment of Disability in Italy: The Laborious Procedure and Sharing of Objectives

“…Following the acknowledgement of the limitations and drawbacks of its slowness, the evaluation process adopted by the ASL and the INPS of Iglesias, in the described framework of 2021, appeared linear, uniform, and facilitated by a substantial agreement of opinions guaranteeing the rights of applicant citizens. Compared to the multifaceted biopsychosocial paradigm adopted by the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF) [ 19 ], the narrower medical model, focused on disease-related impairment, continues to provide, in the procedure described above, the minimum tool necessary to sufficiently verify the requirements of law for the type of disability under consideration. The disability assessment system in Italy appears destined to be radically reformed by law no.…”

Human Functioning: Developments and Grand Challenges

“…Vocational rehabilitation can open the door to employment and the notion of functioning has been shown to be the key metric for assessment of work capacity (29,30), the need for vocational rehabilitation (31), and job matching (32). It remains a challenge to explore the role of functioning as the basis for return-to-work and other work related social strategies, and developing tools that ensure that people experiencing disability are, and remain, active participants in the labor market.…”