SARM1, an octameric NADase, is a key regulator of axon degeneration and an emerging target in small molecule drug discovery to treat a wide range of neurodegenerative diseases. Recently, a structurally diverse series of adduct-forming, orthosteric SARM1 inhibitors have been discovered. Here, we show that subinhibitory concentrations of these orthosteric inhibitors, under mildly SARM1 activating conditions, cause sustained SARM1 activation. This synergistic adverse effect leads to increased nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) consumption, neurodegeneration and release of the biomarker neurofilament-light (NfL) in cultured cortical neurons. In two distinct animal models, we found that low-dose treatment with these orthosteric SARM1 inhibitors results in increased plasma NfL and adverse events when combined with cellular stress or injury conditions. This may present a critical liability for orthosteric SARM1 inhibitors in certain patient populations.