Contextualising missed care in two healthcare inquiries using a socio‐ecological systems approach

Abstract

Aims and objectives To examine missed care within two patient safety public inquiries using a socio‐ecological model. Background Missed care is a care which has been omitted or rendered incomplete. Possible outcomes of missed care have been identified including poor patient outcomes such as higher mortality rates, reduced care quality and lower patient satisfaction, job dissatisfaction, staff burnout and higher attrition rates. Design A qualitative design, specifically document analysis, was used to review two serious case reviews. Methods Between August–December 2018, two public patient safety inquiries were examined using a document analysis method. Both inquiries are based in acute hospital care settings of nursing (UK) and midwifery (Ireland). The Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research checklist provided a framework to report the study methods, context, findings, analysis and interpretation. Results Findings highlighted instances of missed care related to practice which contributed to poor patient outcomes. Missed care was located within contingency factors, such as unintended negative patient health and safety outcomes in multiple system levels which resulted in care deficits. Conclusions A socio‐ecological model enabled consideration of how multi‐system deficits combine to impact nursing and midwifery care delivery. To tackle current and future practice challenges, broader contextual issues that influence front‐line cases should be identified and addressed before they create conditions which result in substandard care. Relevance to clinical practice This paper adds to the scholarship on missed care by incorporating a greater contextual lens. Findings suggest that some factors contributing to missed care events may be systemic in origin. Practice, policy, research and education should foster nurses’ and midwives’ review of the totality of influencing factors impacting missed care and care deficits. Consequently, early warning signs and proactive responses at a system level should be inherent in all settings that nurses’ and midwives’ practice.

Exploring how key performance indicators influence nursing and midwifery practice: A mixed‐methods study

“…They reported being familiar with their KPI data and could relate to how it drove practice change. In these organizations, nurses perceived themselves to have autonomy to act in the best interests of their patients; they challenged authority and adapted practice on their patients' behalf even if it deviated from KPI compliance (Greenhalgh et al, 2014;Phelan & Kirwan, 2020;Rambur et al, 2013). Several authors emphasize that it is those people making the changes in healthcare who know most about the context and the mechanisms that will work to effect change (Berwick, 2015;Cardiff et al, 2020;DoH, 2017b).…”

PROTOCOL: Global elder abuse: A mega‐map of systematic reviews on prevalence, consequences, risk and protective factors and interventions

“…Individuals are affected by, and in turn affect their environments. In addition, reciprocal causation is present, which means individual behaviour moulds, and is moulded by, environment (Phelan & Kirwan, 2020).…”

Missed infection control care and healthcare associated infections: A qualitative study

“…Similarly, Kalisch associates missed nursing care with three antecedents: human resources, material resources, and communication ( Kalisch, Landstrom, & Hinshaw, 2009 ). Both Kalisch and Schubert have devised research surveys to track missed or rationed care, however these tools also function to conceptually reduce care to simple tasks such as ambulation or mouth care, without necessarily contextualizing the tasks within the broader arena of patient care ( Bragadottir, Kalisch, & Brergthoora, 2016 ), although recent publications by the RANCARE group have taken a broader approach drawing on systems theories across a range of institutions including health and education ( Phelan & Kirwan, 2020 ). Phelan and Kirwan demonstrate that nursing is more complex than isolated tasks ( Kitson, Conroy, Kuluski, Locock, & Lyons, 2013 ).…”

“…For example, when a nurse responds to a patient's request for assistance in toileting, they must consider patient safety and privacy, the management of various medical devices attached to the patient, along with infection control precautions. But as Phelan and Kirwan (2020) note, this care may also be dependent on the quality of the education they received.…”