Contextualising ‘Sin’ in Chinese Culture: A Historian's Perspective

Abstract

Is the Christian teaching on sin a ‘stumbling block’ to Chinese accepting Christianity? This paper critiques the notion that Chinese have difficulty comprehending ‘sin’ because of the culture's long-standing belief in the humanistic potential for self-perfection without any reference to the divine. This view of Chinese culture has been too narrow and does not account for the fact that Chinese religious traditions have always had at their disposal a wide variety of resources to comprehend the Christian concept of sin. Incorporating a history-of-practice perspective can contribute to a more productive balance between the representation of Chinese culture and its actual practice and avoid the current tendency to posit Western theology against a narrowly constructed and idealised version of Chinese culture that is severed from both historical and present-day realities.

Searching for meaning in a hybrid and fractured world: Contemporary Chinese cultural identity and its implications for missiology

“… 2. This line of argument suffers from a poor understanding of Chinese religious and legal history. I have addressed this problem elsewhere (Hsu, 2016). …”