Contrasting Narratives of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict in Polish History Textbooks

Abstract

The research critically evaluates ways of narrating the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in Polish secondary-school history textbooks. Based on a repeated critical reading and discourse analysis of both Israeli and Arab-Palestinian narratives, the study focuses on the choice of pro-Palestinian and pro-Israeli designations when naming the conflict and the incorporation or silencing of pro-Israeli and/or pro-Palestinian voices in textbook narratives. Reducing Palestinians to a displaced population and depicting Palestinian liberation movement as terrorism are some elements of the anti-Palestinian/pro-Israeli textbook narrative. Reducing Israel to the status of a Zionist State and presenting Zionism as a colonial movement are the examples of pro-Palestinian textbook narrative. The research found that although the over-simplistic “aggressor-victim” format is not dominant, the coverage of Israeli-Palestinian conflict in most of the analyzed textbooks is unbalanced, sometimes even misleading and implying asymmetrical relations between Jews/Zionists and Arabs/Palestinians.

Exploring perceived challenges, adoption, and assessment of Western values of democracy and human rights in Palestine in the 2023 War on Gaza

“…These sentiments often arise from personal experiences of witnessing or living through the effects of the war 27 . As a result, some individuals have reevaluated their principles and allies, including local Palestinian factions 28 , 29 .…”

Does racism toward nurses increase as treatment invasiveness rises?

“…This study was conducted in Israel where the Jewish majority and the Arab minority citizens harbor animosity to each other due to a lengthy political conflict, which is sometimes violent (Halamish‐Leshem et al, in review; Keshet, 2019; Popper‐Giveon & Keshet, 2021). The focal dispute is over the same territorial region, as each national group claims the entitlement to own and rule this land (Hildebrandt‐Wypych, 2022). This is a conflict between the dominant Jewish majority that constitutes about 75% of Israel's population and the Arab minority that constitutes about 21% (Gaya, 2022; Israel Central Bureau of Statistics, 2021; Smooha, 2019).…”