Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease characterized by pancreatic β cell destruction. It is a complex genetic trait driven by >30 genetic loci with parallels between humans and mice. The NOD mouse spontaneously develops autoimmune diabetes and is widely used to identify insulin-dependent diabetes (Idd) genetic loci linked to diabetes susceptibility. Although many Idd loci have been extensively studied, the impact of the Idd2 locus on autoimmune diabetes susceptibility remains to be defined. To address this, we generated a NOD congenic mouse bearing B10 resistance alleles on chromosome 9 in a locus coinciding with part of the Idd2 locus and found that NOD.B10-Idd2 congenic mice are highly resistant to diabetes. Bone marrow chimera and adoptive transfer experiments showed that the B10 protective alleles provide resistance in an immune cell–intrinsic manner. Although no T cell–intrinsic differences between NOD and NOD.B10-Idd2 mice were observed, we found that the Idd2 resistance alleles limit the formation of spontaneous and induced germinal centers. Comparison of B cell and dendritic cell transcriptome profiles from NOD and NOD.B10-Idd2 mice reveal that resistance alleles at the Idd2 locus affect the expression of specific MHC molecules, a result confirmed by flow cytometry. Altogether, these data demonstrate that resistance alleles at the Idd2 locus impair germinal center formation and influence MHC expression, both of which likely contribute to reduced diabetes incidence.