Contribution of maternal age and pregnancy checkbox on maternal mortality ratios in the United States, 1978–2012

Abstract

BACKGROUND Maternal mortality ratios (MMR) appear to have increased in the United States over the last decade. Three potential contributing factors are (1) a shifting maternal age distribution, (2) changes in age-specific MMR, and (3) the addition of a checkbox indicating recent pregnancy on the death certificate. OBJECTIVE To determine the contribution of increasing maternal age on changes in MMR from 1978 to 2012 and estimate the contribution of the pregnancy checkbox on increases in MMR over the last decade. STUDY DESIGN Kitagawa decomposition analyses were conducted to partition the maternal age contribution to the MMR increase into 2 components: changes due to a shifting maternal age distribution and changes due to greater age-specific mortality ratios. We used National Vital Statistics System natality and mortality data. The following 5-year groupings were used: 1978–1982, 1988–1992, 1998–2002, and 2008–2012. Changes in age-specific MMRs among states that adopted the standard pregnancy checkbox onto their death certificate before 2008 (n = 23) were compared with states that had not adopted the standard pregnancy checkbox on their death certificate by the end of 2012 (n = 11) to estimate the percentage increase in the MMR due to the pregnancy checkbox. RESULTS Overall US MMRs for 1978–1982, 1988–1992, and 1998–2002 were 9.0, 8.1, and 9.1 deaths per 100,000 live births, respectively. There was a modest increase in the MMR between 1998–2002 and 2008–2012 in the 11 states that had not adopted the standard pregnancy checkbox on their death certificate by the end of 2012 (8.6 and 9.9 deaths per 100,000, respectively). However, the MMR more than doubled between 1998–2002 and 2008–2012 in the 23 states that adopted the standard pregnancy checkbox (9.0–22.4); this dramatic increase was almost entirely attributable to increases in age-specific MMRs (94.9%) as opposed to increases in maternal age (5.1%), with an estimated 90% of the observed change reflecting the change in maternal death identification rather than a real change in age-specific rates alone. Of all age categories, women ages 40 and older in states that adopted the standard pregnancy checkbox had the largest increase in MMR—from 31.9 to 200.5—a relative increase of 528%, which accounted for nearly one third of the overall increase. An estimated 28.8% of the observed change was potentially due to maternal death misclassification among women ≥ 40 years. CONCLUSION Increasing age-specific maternal mortality seems to be contributing more heavily than a changing maternal age distribution to recent increases in MMR. In states with the standard pregnancy checkbox, the vast majority of the observed change in MMR over the last decade was estimated to be due to the pregnancy checkbox, with the greatest change in MMR occurring in women ages ≥ 40 years. The addition of a pregnancy checkbox on state death certificates appears to be increasing case identification but also may be leading to maternal death misclassification, particularly for women ages ≥ 40 ye...

Trends in pregnancy-associated mortality involving opioids in the United States, 2007–2016

“…4 Data from this study come from death certificates, which are known to include reporting errors related to both pregnancy status and use of opioids. 2,5 Despite this limitation, the findings indicate that interventions are urgently needed to reverse these concerning trends.…”

“…1 Among commercially insured women, we observed overall decreases in hysterectomy utilization of 9e17% for abnormal uterine bleeding, uterine leiomyoma, and endometriosis from 2010 through 2013. 2 We hypothesized that these decreases in hysterectomy utilization were associated with a concurrently increasing use of LNG-IUD and described financial implications of these changes.…”

Checking the pregnancy checkbox: Evaluation of a four‐state quality assurance pilot

“…Although the addition of the pregnancy checkbox to the standard death certificate resulted in increased identification of maternal deaths, many researchers have raised questions about its accuracy . The staggered adoption of the revised death certificate by states resulted in a lack of nationally comparable data, and NCHS has not released an official United States MMR since 2007 .…”

“…A subsequent Texas study found that 50% of obstetric‐coded deaths in 2012 showed no evidence of pregnancy within 42 days of death after data‐matching—suggesting that the reported increase in maternal deaths was inflated by pregnancy checkbox errors . These studies question the accuracy of United States maternal death data, highlighting the necessity of data quality improvement measures …”

Uncovering the stories behind the numbers : a case study of maternal death surveillance and response in Goma, Democratic Republic of Congo.

“…Given its national scope and ability to produce real-time data on births and deaths, it is considered the gold standard for measuring maternal mortality (Blencowe, Calvert, Lawn, Cousens, & Campbell, 2016;Scott & Danel, 2016;WHO, et al, 2015). Maternal death identification via CRVS is facilitated by a pregnancy checkbox on the death certificate where implemented, indicating pregnancy status at death in addition to cause of death information (Davis, Hoyert, Goodman, Hirai, & Callaghan, 2017;Horon & Cheng, 2011;MacKay, Rochat, Smith, & Berg, 2000).…”