“…Inspired by previous cooperatively-catalyzed NHC annulations, conditions using lithium chloride, [3e, 6b] titanium isopropoxide, [9c] scandium triflate, [12e] zinc triflate, magnesium di-tert-butoxide, [12a, 12e] and HBDs as co-catalysts were screened with no improvement to the enantioselectivity (see SI). A variety of magnesium and calcium alkoxides and HBDs were screened as co-catalysts with azolium A , which led to moderate enantioselectivities (32–45% ee, entries 2–3 and SI).…”