Cordon of Conformity: Why DSGE Models AreNotthe Future of Macroeconomics

Abstract

The Rebuilding Macroeconomic Theory Project, led by David Vines and Samuel Wills (2020), is an important, albeit long overdue, initiative to rethink a failing mainstream macroeconomics. Professors Vines and Wills, who must be congratulated for stepping up to the challenge of trying to make mainstream macroeconomics relevant again, call for a new multipleequilibrium and diverse (MEADE) paradigm for macroeconomics. Their idea is to start with simple models, ideally two-dimensional sketches, that explain mechanisms that can cause multiple equilibria. These mechanisms should then be incorporated into larger DSGE models in a new, multipleequilibrium synthesisto see how the fundamental pieces of the economy fit together, subject to it being "properly micro-founded". This paper argues that the MEADE paradigm is bound to fail, because it maintains the DSGE model as the unifying framework at the center of macroeconomic analysis. The paper reviews 10 fundamental weaknesses inherent in DSGE models which make these models irreparably useless for macroeconomic policy analysis. Mainstream macroeconomics must put DSGE models, once and for all, in the Museum of Implausible Economic Modelsand learn important lessons from non-DSGE macroeconomic approaches.

Theorizing Varieties of Capitalism: economics and the fallacy that 'there is no alternative (TINA)'

“…It draws its inspiration from Arrow-Debreu (1954) theory but modifies the CGE model to incorporate nominal rigidities and market failures. That approach has been substantively criticized (see Dullien 2009;Podkamminer 2021;Storm 2021).…”

Inflation in the Time of Corona and War: The plight of the developing economies

“…The ruthless monetary tightening in the US by Paul Volcker's Federal Reserve, combined with brutal labor market deregulation, brought down US inflation, but at the cost of two successive American recessions, a global recession, and a wave of debt crises in developing countries, especially in those of Latin America and Africa, which morphed into two decades lost to economic development. The policy turn was also followed by a fundamental reorientation in macroeconomic thinking-as Keynesian economics was buried in favor of New-Classical economics dressed up as New Keynesian economics (Storm 2021).…”

Inflation in the Time of Corona and War

“…18 The new practice of explicit signaling has also sparked a large, fanciful, literature investigating the properties and implications of forward guidance. It is fair to conclude that while forward guidance has been found to be a powerful monetary policy tool in empirically sterile DSGE models (Rudd 2021;Storm 2021), it has proven to be far from easy to implement effectively in practice.…”

“…Macroeconomists can contribute to this reimagination of macroeconomic policy-but to do so, they will have to fundamentally reconsider their thinking in order to make macroeconomics relevant for the real world (again) and this requires getting rid of their E-DSGE models as soon as possible (Storm 2021). The stakes are very high.…”