Correlates of mental disorders among minority Arab adolescents in Israel: results from the Galilee Study

Abstract

BackgroundThe Galilee Study is the first large epidemiological study to compare correlates of mental disorders between two Arab Palestinian minority groups of adolescents in Israel.MethodsA two-stage cross-sectional study, carried out between 2012 and 2014, included all 9th grade students from 5 Arab localities, representative of 77% of the Muslim and 100% of Druze citizens in Israel. During the screening stage, 1639 students completed the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire in the classroom (response rate = 69.3%). During the follow-up stage, 704 adolescent-mother dyads were interviewed at home; using the Development and Well-Being Assessment, the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ)-12, the Subjective Feeling of Discrimination Index (FDI), and socio-demographic questions (response rate = 84.4%).ResultsPrevalence of any disorder, internalizing or externalizing disorders among Muslim adolescents were 19.2, 15.8 and 4.2%, respectively and among Druze adolescents 10.9, 5.9 and 5.5%, respectively. Muslim adolescents were 3.2 times more likely than Druze adolescents to have an internalizing disorder, while Druze were 2 times more likely than Muslim to have an externalizing disorder. Males were at higher risk than females for externalizing disorders in both populations, though among Druze the risk was more striking. Learning disabilities increased the likelihood of having an externalizing disorder in both populations. Risk factors for internalizing disorders among Muslim adolescents were female gender, a very low socio-economic level, few siblings, LD, high maternal GHQ-12 score and high FDI; and for externalizing disorders, male gender, a relatively low socio-economic level but not the lowest, learning disability and high maternal GHQ-12 score.ConclusionsWe found an association between religion/ethnicity and internalizing and externalizing disorders as well as a strong correlation between religion/ethnicity and socio-economic variables. Therefore, we tend to conclude that not religion per se but the multifaceted socio-cultural and economic factors that characterize religious groups are associated with mental disorders. Very low socio-economic level and feeling discriminated which were traits connected only to Muslim adolescents, were associated with internalizing disorders. When preparing preventive measures aimed at furthering mental health among minority adolescents, authorities should focus on improving the socio-economic status of minorities and reducing institutional and personal discrimination. The educational and mental health establishments could undertake measures to improve resilience and coping strategies of Muslim families living in the most adverse conditions, such as providing special support through the school counseling services and coordinating, at the ministerial levels, school and community health services in order to carry out joint preventive programs and referrals to specialist services when needed.

Exposing the Secret: Listening to Bedouin Men Who Have Experienced Sexual Violence

“…Men who report being the victim of SV can be stigmatized as a result of a perceived lack of machismo and other denigrations of their masculinity (Migliaccio, 2001). Similar to what has been observed in other traditional ethnic minority groups (Daeem et al, 2019), mental health problems in Bedouin society are associated with social stigma and are often concealed (Slobodin et al, 2011). The strict and overriding social stigmatization of direct expressions of emotional distress in Arab culture (Kafaji, 2011) encourages strategies of minimization and avoidance (Slobodin et al, 2014) that interfere with help-seeking behavior.…”

Middle eastern refugee children and adolescents mental health: A systematic review

“…Exposure to short and long‐term violence negatively impacts children's mental, emotional, behavioural, social, and physical well‐being (Daeem et al . 2019; Miller‐Graff & Cummings 2017; Shehadeh 2021; UNICEF 2019; Wolmer et al . 2013).…”

“…Children of Muslim, Jewish, Christian, and other ethnic minority groups face considerable challenges in fulfilling their real potential and becoming active citizens due to the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Exposure to short and longterm violence negatively impacts children's mental, emotional, behavioural, social, and physical well-being (Daeem et al 2019;Miller-Graff & Cummings 2017;Shehadeh 2021;UNICEF 2019;Wolmer et al 2013).…”

Associations between socioprovincial factors and self-reported mental disorders among students from grade 4 to 8 in rural China

“…Furthermore, a study reported race moderated the link between physical discipline and externalizing behavior problems for European American adolescents during Grades 6 and 8 [ 10 ]. Another large epidemiological study in Israel found an association between religion/ethnicity and internalizing and externalizing disorders in Muslim adolescents [ 11 ].…”