Correlating Quantitative Measurements of Radical Production by Photocatalytic TiO₂ with Daphnia magna Toxicity

Abstract

Increased use of titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanoparticles (NPs) in domestic and industrial applications has increased the risk for adverse environmental outcomes based on an elevated likelihood of organism exposure. Anatase TiO2 NP exposure to ultraviolet A (UV‐A) radiation in aquatic environments generates radical oxygen species (ROS), which may ultimately be responsible for increased organism toxicity. We have identified and measured the 2 most relevant ROS species, hydroxyl and superoxide radicals, and described that ROS can be modeled using the highly reactive hydroxyl radical to provide an upper bound for toxicity. The TiO2 NPs were co‐exposed to increasing natural organic matter (NOM) amounts (measured as concentration of dissolved organic carbon [DOC]) and simulated‐sunlight UV‐A intensities. Radical production rate was determined using fluorescence spectroscopy and was positively correlated with increases in TiO2 concentration and UV‐A intensity, and negatively correlated with increased DOC concentration. Daphnia magna toxicity was also found to decrease with NOM addition, which is attributed to the decreased radical production rate with increased DOC concentrations. We demonstrate that the rate of ROS production from simulated‐sunlight–irradiated TiO2 NPs can be quantified using relatively simple fluorescent techniques. We show that toxicity to TiO2 NP varies greatly with conditions, and that concentration alone is a poor predictor of toxicity. Describing toxicity/hydroxyl radical measurement may be a more accurate way to describe overall risk. We provide a framework for a simple model to describe toxicity/hydroxyl radical. These conclusions demonstrate the importance of considering exposure conditions as a means of risk management during TiO2 NP toxicity testing, waste management, and regulatory decisions. Environ Toxicol Chem 2021;40:1322–1334. © 2021 SETAC

UV‐dependent freshwater effect factor of nanoscale titanium dioxide for future life cycle assessment application

“…Coral et al (2021) indicated that ROS production is positively correlated with the increasing of TiO 2 concentration and UV‐A intensity. Because most toxicity data collected for EF derivatives were based on laboratory exposures and lacked the consideration of realistic freshwater exposures.…”

Antibacterial, antifungal, antiviral, and photocatalytic activities of TiO2 nanoparticles, nanocomposites, and bio-nanocomposites: Recent advances and challenges

“…25 Some research suggests that the structure of anatase can destroy a bacterial membrane and cell wall by generating negative hydroxyl free radicals ( * OH) in a photocatalytic reaction. 26 These properties are clearly explained in the below section.…”

Platelet bioenergetic profiling uncovers a metabolic pattern of high dependency on mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation in type 2 diabetic patients who developed in-stent restenosis

“…So, after staining platelets with DHR123, the increment in fluorescence of R123, as continuously recorded (λ ex/em = 485/528 nm) by a plate reader (BMG LABTECH, Germany), is proportional to the rate of mtROS generation [ 28 ]. For each sample, the average rate of mtROS generation is expressed as the slope of a linear regression line fitted to the fluorometric data [ 29 ].…”