Correspondence between objective and perceived walking times to urban destinations: Influence of physical activity, neighbourhood walkability, and socio-demographics

Abstract

BackgroundDoing regular physical activity has positive effects on health. Several environmental factors are identified as important correlates of physical activity. However, there seems to be a difference between perceived and objective measures of the environment. This study examines the influence of physical activity, neighbourhood walkability, and socio-demographic characteristics on the correspondence between self-reported and objectively measured walking time to urban destinations of adults in the city of Ghent (Belgium).MethodsPreviously collected survey data was used from 1164 respondents in the city of Ghent who reported walking times to various closest destinations in the neighbourhood of residence. These were compared with corresponding walking times that were objectively measured through geographical information systems. Physical activity was recorded over a 7-day period using accelerometers. Neighbourhood walkability was assessed on the basis of residential density, connectivity, and land-use mix.ResultsWe observed a relatively poor agreement between objective and perceived walking times. Stronger agreements were noted amongst the most physically active group, while low-level walkers tended to overestimate walking time. Surprisingly, however, people residing in a low-walkable neighbourhood underestimated walking times more frequently relative to those in high-walkable neighbourhoods.ConclusionsResearchers investigating the influence of environmental attributes on physical activity behavior should thus be cautious when using only self-reported environmental data, since these are a priori influenced by physical activity levels and various socio-demographic factors.

Accessibility to primary health care in Belgium: an evaluation of policies awarding financial assistance in shortage areas

“…However, like Apparicio [16], we found a strong positive correlation between both the shortest network distance and car travel time (two-tailed Pearson r = 0.949, p < 0.001), and therefore in this paper we only elucidate the results using network distances. Also, network distances are preferred because we did not want to presuppose the transport mode used to get to a physician by using mode-specific speeds for calculating travel time [2,16,33]. …”

How urban densification shapes walking behaviours in older community dwellers: a cross-sectional analysis of potential pathways of influence

“…It is possible that interconnected street networks may make it easier for older adults to walk longer distances or that older adults having to cross more roads en route may tend to define their neighbourhood (15-minute walk from home) as a smaller area than those living in neighbourhoods with fewer crossings. Studies utilising Global Positioning System (GPS) or smartphone technology are needed to clarify this finding as self-report measures of walking within and outside the neighbourhood rely on participants' perceptions of the duration of walking trips which can be inaccurate [55,56].…”

Active transportation in adult survivors of childhood cancer and neighborhood controls

“…Greater access (perceived and objective) to destinations has been the most consistent individual environmental correlate of active transportation despite a fair amount of discordance between objective and perceived walkability [32,43,45–47]. Other environmental correlates such as street connectivity, aesthetics, and the presence of sidewalks have shown mixed results, along with measures of social support and safety [43].…”