Cost and time performance of traditional-, direct labour- and management-procured public projects in Ondo State, Nigeria

Abstract

Procurement method over time has proven to have significant influence on the successful delivery of construction projects. Making the right decision in the selection of a procurement option to adopt is therefore crucial if a project is to succeed. This study therefore assessed the cost and time performance of selected public building projects procured using traditional, direct labour and management procurement options in Ondo State, Nigeria. A pro forma was used to gather cost and time data from government procuring entities in the state. In addition, a structured questionnaire was used to obtain information from construction professionals in these procuring entities, in order to ascertain the factors influencing the choice of procurement options adopted. The cost and time data gathered were analyzed using percentages and the paired-samples t-test, while those gathered on the factors influencing the choice of procurement options were analyzed using mean item scores and analysis of variance (ANOVA). The results revealed that although there is no significant difference between the initial and final costs of the assessed projects, some measure of cost overrun still exists. In addition, a considerable amount of time overrun was experienced on projects executed using the three different procurement options. The most significant factors influencing the choice of a procurement option are price competition, speed, time certainty and complexity of the project. It is believed that the findings of this study will provide public procuring entities with insight on the cost and time capability of these procurement methods and aid them in selecting the procurement option that will help in delivering public building projects within the budget and on schedule.

An Analysis of Appropriate Procurement Method for Delivery of Quality Public Buildings: The Case of Constituency Offices

“…The findings from this study align with research conducted by (Jimoh, Oyewobi, & Aliu, 2016) and (Aghimien, Osanyinro, & Adegbembo, 2016) which focused on evaluating procurement methods in the Nigerian construction industry. These studies identified factors such as quality, cost, duration, and project complexity as significant influencers in the choice of procurement method.…”

The relationship between labour-only procurement and health and safety performance of construction projects

“…Examining 32 LoPS projects in Nigeria, Akinkunmi et al (2018) found a 2% cost saving overall. Given the harsh economic conditions in many countries including Nigeria and the 4.87% saving in educational projects procured through other routes in Nigeria found in Aghimien et al (2017), it can be argued that the saving LoPS provides is significant. According to Ogunsanmi (2013), the poor economic climate of Nigeria contributes to the increased adoption of LoPS.…”

“…(2018) found a 2% cost saving overall. Given the harsh economic conditions in many countries including Nigeria and the 4.87% saving in educational projects procured through other routes in Nigeria found in Aghimien et al. (2017), it can be argued that the saving LoPS provides is significant.…”