Cost-Effective Training Models in Point-of-Care Ultrasound for Medical Students in Emergency Medicine: An Evaluation of Current Resources

Abstract

BackgroundUltrasound is becoming more widely utilized in clinical practice; however, its effectiveness is limited by the operator's skills. Simulation models are attractive options for developing skills because they allow inexperienced users to practice without the risk of endangering patients. ObjectiveThe purpose of this study was to identify commercially available and homemade ultrasound models to describe them in terms of materials, cost, and whether they are high-or low-fidelity for medical student education. MethodsThis is an investigational study on cost-effective ultrasound training methods for medical students. Our study was performed using search engines in Google, Google Scholar, and PubMed to search for models for the following five modalities: foreign body identification, intravenous (IV) injection training, abdominal ultrasound, ocular ultrasound, and ultrasound-guided lumbar puncture training. ResultsMost homemade models for foreign body identification, IV injection training, and ocular ultrasound could be created for less than $20. IV injection training models were the cheapest commercially available models. There are multiple commercially available options for abdominal ultrasound models, but no options were found for homemade construction. The construction cost for lumbar puncture models was larger due to the need to purchase an anatomically accurate set of lumbar vertebrae. ConclusionsThis study provides initial guidance and suggestions for ultrasound training models that are currently available. Ultrasound models that can be cheaply made or purchased increase accessibility for medical students to gain early exposure in a cost-effective and safe manner.

Do-It-Yourself Ultrasonography Phantom Model for Improving Hand Skills: A Technical Report

“…However, the expense of high-fidelity simulators and phantoms may be unaffordable for institutions with little funding, particularly in developing countries with low per capita income [6]. A number of researchers have shared their simple, affordable, and high-fidelity ultrasound simulation phantom models [6][7][8].…”

Utilizing 3-Dimensional Cardiac Models With Point-of-Care Ultrasound Video Tutorials to Improve Medical Student Education: A Double-Blinded Randomized Control Study

“…Albeit the many flaws discussed, there is a growing interest in the integration of bedside ultrasound, anatomy, and models or simulation trainers. There is an abundance of commercially available ultrasound simulation models as well as homemade cost-effective models [7][8][9]. The numerous innovative approaches to education have demonstrated a theme that students prefer these ultrasound demonstrations.…”

Novel Cost-Effective Model for Training Post-intubation Endotracheal Tube Placement Confirmation

“…For the mold a plastic Tupperware container holding 1 L was used, but any square container will suffice. The gelatin model was made using a mixture of four cups of boiling water, 41 g of psyllium to 84 g of gelatin [ 8 ]. Once the water was brought to a boil, the gelatin was slowly mixed in while stirring to prevent clumping.…”